Friday, August 6, 2010

Freedom of Religion is Freedom to Offend

People who support using the government to prevent the building of the Cordoba House, also known as the Ground Zero Mosque, speak as if all of Islam now is some special category where the freedom to peacefully gather and worship on one's own property is now qualified by sensitivity to mainstream America. As if freedom of religion is merely the freedom to choose between the little white church on the green grassy hill and the megachurch in the suburbs. Freedom of religion is not just for the wholesome, the familiar, and the unoffensive. Freedom of religion is for the ones who feel called to be different. It's for the peculiar people. It's for the ones who think everyone else is going to hell. It's for the ones who go door to door asking people how they know they're not going to hell. It's for the ones who won't entrust broader society with the education of their children, and who teach their kids at home or in private schools where they assign them weird science books with unorthodox slants on natural history. It's for the girls who insist on wearing long skirts and maybe even bonnets in public. And it's for the girls who want to wear veils too. It's not just for people who want to burn candles or refrain from burning candles; it's also for the ones who want to grow long black beards and bow down and touch their faces to the ground. Freedom of religion is not for the followers of familiar and unoffensive paths. Those people have social nostalgia on their side. Freedom of religion is for the weird, the awkward, and the offensive. If the freedom of religion you believe in is to make any sense, then you have to be willing to be offended. And if you're unwilling to be offended by a religious practice that violates no one's rights, then you don't deserve to be called a patriot, or even an American.

5 comments:

  1. Totally agree. Faved the video.

    ReplyDelete
  2. That "Modest Handmaidens" site is really something. I wonder how many women like that kind of fashion--though on the other hand it doesn't bother me that I don't meet them.

    Feminism certainly has its negative points, but I absolutely wouldn't hold that up as its best opposite. Also, when people see homeschooling materials being sold on a site like that, I'm a little less surprised when they don't view it as the path to freedom.

    But yes, religious freedom is "for the weird" as you put it.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Oh, and in that "soul winning video", I found it weird how he said that God punishes us for our sins by sending us into the lake of fire, but yet he loves us and so doesn't want us to get that punishment. Well, which is it? I almost couldn't have said that with a straight face.

    ReplyDelete
  4. About feminism, I think people have to be careful to use the term in a way that recognizes that there are a variety of strands within the movement. Brainpolice has a few neat videos on femenism, the most recent of which is here. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b1uQj6TysQs

    ReplyDelete
  5. About soulwinning, when he was still alive George Carlin did a great show about religion (and especially conventional Crhistianity).

    A lot of people try to explain the "you'll go to Hell but God loves you" line by saying that God cannot let imperfection into Heaven. Hell is then more or less a storage place to put imperfect souls. Of course, supposing that God is all-powerful, you'd think He can put together a place to store imperfect souls without subjecting them to an eternity of gratuitous misery. This kind of response can only work (if at all) on a particular strand of Evangelical Christians - the ones who say "but God LOVES us..." There are some Christians who say that God truly does hate the unsaved (Westboro Baptist Church being a prime example). Then there are other Christians who don't believe in Hell at all (for instance, Jehovah's Witnesses).

    ReplyDelete

Followers

About Me

My photo
I am a part-time philosopher and a former immigration paralegal with a BA in philosophy and a paralegal certificate from UC San Diego.