Last week I made the mistake of admitting to someone at my workplace that I'm an anarchist.
"Can I ask you a question?" she asked.
"Sure," I said.
"Do you drive?"
"Yes."
"How do you put up with it?"
"Put up with what?"
"Stop signs. Traffic lights. Police pulling people over..."
She was one of the many who think that rejecting inherent political authority means rejecting law and order, as if there can be no such thing as law without government. But I condemn government, not because I condemn law, but because I find government to be completely incompatible with the one law that matters most - individual sovereignty.
"I have no problem with rules," I responded. "I just think people should be allowed to choose which rules to follow."
The one law (or maybe I should say one of the few laws) which isn't up for choice, but which is rightfully thrust onto everyone without their consent, is the obligation to leave others to enjoy themselves. Every other law, and every other governing body, and every other person or group of persons that wishes to exercise control over a man or his things, requires his consent, and has no authority over him without his consent.
Government laws prohibiting the manufacture, possession, use, or distribution of certain drugs are illegitimate, since they prohibit an act which harms no one and they lack the consent of the subjects. They imply that government has the right to control the bodies of its subjects.
The libertarian maxim on criminal law is "No victim, no crime." If no one is limiting another's liberty through a violent act against their body or property, or through a threat of violence against their body or property, then no one's liberty was violated, no one was victimized, and no one has a right to react forcefully.
Some libertarians have taken their rejection of victimless crimes so far that they reject laws against drunk driving. Since a crime is only committed when there is a victim, they argue, driving with an alcohol content above a specified amount should not be considered a crime. If a drunk driver drives recklessly and crashes into someone else's car and other people have to be rushed to the hospital, then the drunk driver can be prosecuted for endangering other people's lives, injuring other people, and damaging other people's property. But he should not, according to these libertarians, be prosecuted for the content of his blood. What matters is whether his actions deny someone else's sovereignty over themselves. If no one is injured, deprived, or threatened by his actions, then there is no victim, and whether he has a noticeable amount of alcohol in his body is irrelevant.
I originally wanted to respond to this line of reasoning by assaying whether drunk (or some other kind of reckless) driving poses such a threat to others that it can be treated like pulling a gun on someone. I guess I'll say very quickly that if the fear instilled by drunk drivers is so great that people actually refrain from setting foot or wheel on public roads, then yes, drunk and other reckless driving on public roads could and should be treated like any other threat that denies other people's liberty and against which people may forcefully react. But this argument only pertains to public roads, and it doesn't account for the rich diversity that would be able to exist in a free society.
Every good libertarian and classical liberal knows that we should be allowed to have private roads (and some libertarians believe that a system of private roads would be more efficient than what we have). We don't violate anyone's liberty by paving a strip of our own property and driving on it. Every good libertarian and classical liberal also knows that we should be allowed to do just about whatever we want on our own roads. If you want to ghost ride in your own driveway, parking lot, or road, that's your choice.
People already engage in activities that threaten their own lives and the lives of others, and only the most parternalist among us would call for those activities to be banned. If you want to race your own very light and very fast car on a race track, go ahead. You don't violate anyone's rights by driving that fast on that race track. So long as everyone else on the track knows that people are driving dangerously fast, and so long as the race track owners allow you to drive that fast, no one's rights are violated. If you are to be free, you should be free to take onto yourself whatever risk is necessary to pursue your own happiness. The courts are starting to disagree, but deep down inside we all know that if you want to drive like an idiot with other consenting idiots, that's your choice.
If there can be race tracks where drivers waive each other's liability and drive in a way that endangers themselves and each other without legal consequence, why shouldn't we be allowed to have private roads where drivers and passengers can do the same? From a property rights perspective, there seems to be a clear case for legally allowing private road owners to permit drunk driving on their roads.
This isn't to say, though, that all road owners have the obligation to allow drunk driving on their roads. Far be it. Road owners have the moral right to exclude drunk drivers, just as pub owners have the right to kick out belligerent drunks. To say that anyone has a moral and enforceable obligation to provide services to someone they don't want to serve is to condone slavery. And to say that anyone can be forced to allow others access to their property is to say that their property isn't really theirs to begin with. And so, from a property rights perspective, road owners have the right to keep drunk drivers and other reckless drivers off their road.
Over the past three years that I've been reading libertarian legal theory, I've noticed some anonymous fringe elements condemning police outright, and denying any right of police to pull people over or arrest anyone. Those attitudes might be libertarian in spirit, but they aren't libertarian in theory. Individual sovereignty implies that people be allowed to use proportionate and discriminate force to address threats (i.e., defensive violence is permissible), and if we should be free to hire chefs to cook for us and bus drivers to drive for us, we should also be free to hire police to protect us. And, since individual sovereignty implies each property owner's right to determine the conditions of use (that is, the rules) on his or her property, road owners have the right to employ police to pull over reckless or suspicious drivers.
Suppose I had my own house, and suppose also that I threw a party in it. One of my male guests makes some unpleasant comments about the human female, and out of consideration of my female guests I pull the guy to the side and explain to him that he can't be saying things like that at my party. If he continues, or if he goes ahead and gropes someone, I have the right to physically take hold of him and throw him out of my house. In fact, I don't have to wait for him to offend my guests, or do something that everyone acknowledges as offensive. If he so much as puts on a Che Guevara shirt, I have the right to throw him out, and to say otherwise is to say that the house I bought really doesn't belong to me. Now, I don't have the right to beat him for it, or lock him in the basement (unless he gets violent and that's the only safe place for him). I'm only entitled to use so much force as is necessary to stay sovereign over myself and what is mine, or to maintain other people's sovereignty over themselves and what is theirs.
The same goes for roads. Road owners have the right to come up with their own rules for their own roads, and they have the right to enforce those rules. Their police have the right to pull over people who don't follow those rules, to fine people who break those rules, and to drive home people who they think shouldn't be driving. Now, they wouldn't have the right to imprison people indefinitely or without cause (that's kidnapping). But they do have the right to remove from the road those drivers who break the road owner's rules, and that means they should have the right to pull people over, and chase down and set up road blocks for those who don't pull over. If I have the right to pull a guy to the side in my party, or throw him out of my house, then highway patrol should have the right to pull over people who break the road owners' rules.
Hopefully, those rules won't get too ridiculous. There's a chance that they would. Someone might strictly enforce a no bumper stickers rule, or cite people for having chrome that's too shiny. We can trust, though, that competition in roads and road security would render the most relevant and least intrusive policies, since road owners whose rules are absolutely uncalled for wouldn't see a whole lot of business and would be allowed to fail.
Now to qualify what was just said about private roads and private traffic laws. In the video I linked in the above paragraph, Walter Block suggested someone try implementing the death penalty for drunk driving. The audience laughed, and probably most of them thought he was joking. I'm quite sure he wasn't. Block thinks it's theoretically possible to voluntarily and peacefully alienate your right to live. He could and probably would argue that a driver signs away his right to live when he drives drunk on a road that is clearly marked with signs saying "Drunk drivers will be shot." Without writing a book about it, let me say that a driver doesn't alienate his right to live by driving on a road any more than a guest alienates his right to live by stepping foot in someone else's house. If he opens fire on police, or aims a gun at another driver, that's a different story. (I say more about retaliatory force in my entry on abortion.)
At any rate, even if a road owner were to have drunk drivers executed, I doubt that rule would take off. Rather than encourage drivers to not drive drunk, it would encourage drunk drivers to not get caught. Chases on those roads would be much more violent than on the other roads, and that would increase the cost of keeping that road. Also, people would want to use other roads if they know they could possibly be executed for driving funny or tired. Roads with that rule wouldn't see much business. And, if executions are so controversial, the road owners run the risk of getting boycotted.
Before closing, I'd like to underline that though road owners in a free society would be free to write and enforce their own traffic laws, they would not be free to perform disproportionate or nondiscriminate acts of violence on drivers or passengers. If it is a free society, then individual sovereignty would be the rule of law, and any act that punishes the wrong person, or punishes someone too much, would be considered illegal, and other people would have the legally-recognized right to prevent it.
Also, I should mention that private roads doesn't mean no public roads. Roderick Long has two essays, here and here, where he argues that public space is not only permitted by libertarian principles, but is also desirable, and would likely appear in a free society. Land does not need to be government-owned to be owned by and freely available to the general public. The question of who to write the traffic rules, what traffic rules to write, and how to enforce traffic rules on public roads in a free society is a question worth asking, and unfortunately a complete answer to it won't fit here. The very short answer is common law and mediation.
If you are bothered by the complexity and otherness of a system like this, just ask yourself these three questions. Should people be allowed to drive drunk on their own roads? Should people be allowed to drive drunk on roads designated for drunk driving? Should people be allowed to drive on roads where drunk driving is prohibited? If you answer "Yes" to the first, then I don't see why you shouldn't also answer "Yes" to the second. And who in their right mind wouldn't answer "Yes" to the third? If you answer "Yes" to all three of those questions (and I don't know any red-blooded American who wouldn't), then you basically want a system like the one I call for.
Tuesday, September 8, 2009
Sunday, August 30, 2009
Dress Standards on Public Transportation, and other things
You're sitting on a public bus, and your stop is about half an hour away. The bus is gradually getting more crowded, and newcomers are standing in the aisle holding on to hand rails. A man gets on and stands right in front of you. He acts completely normally - he says "Excuse me" and "Thank you", he awkwardly smiles the way you're supposed to on a crowded city bus, etc. - but there's one thing that makes him look more than a little unusual, and which makes other people feel very uncomfortable. He's completely naked.
This is a city bus - it's supposed to be for everybody who either can't or doesn't want to ride in a car or ride a bike. And we know that, in freer societies like ours, we're supposed to be free to do with ourselves as we please. Is it okay to kick him off the bus, or to not allow him on the bus in the first place? In some cases, yes. But wouldn't that violate his sovereignty over himself? I don't think so.
You should be free to walk around your own bedroom and bathroom naked. If your curtains are drawn, you should be free to walk around your entire house completely naked. If your neighbors permit, you should be free to walk around their house completely naked. If the owner of a restaurant permits, you should be perfectly free to sit at a table and enjoy a meal completely naked. You do not, however, have the right to present yourself unclothed on the property of anyone who doesn't consent to your nudity. You have sovereignty over yourself and what is yours; you do not have sovereignty over other people and their property.
We see the signs in restaurants that say "No shoes, no shirt, no service", and we never think twice about whether excluding someone who isn't properly clothed according to that sign violates those people's rights. Restaurant owners want to maintain a certain atmosphere that caters to a particular segment of the population (those who don't want to be offended by the presence of shirtless people), and to run their business the way they want to run it (which they have a right to) they have to make clear certain rules about how they want their property used. When a shirtless man walks in, no one violates his rights by refusing to take his order. If he really wants to have a shirtless restaurant experience, he could go to a restaurant that caters to people who don't mind the presence of shirtless patrons.
So, if a naked man gets on a bus where nudity is forbidden by the owner, the driver has every right to keep him from getting on. The only problem with applying this line of reasoning to city buses is that city buses belong to "the city" and not anyone in particular. But that isn't a problem with this line of reasoning. That's a problem with the oxymoronic idea of "public" ownership. Things that are publicly owned are supposedly owned and run by everybody for everybody. But we know that "public" services are funded by one segment of society (not everybody), distributed by another segment of society (again, not everybody) for the benefit of a very select segment of society (again, not everybody).
But I think I can address the problem of dress standards on public transportation without opining that tax subsidies for public transportation violate individuals' property rights, or that the most efficient mass transit is private mass transit.
As I wrote above, the restaurant managers want to cater to a certain crowd, and to do that they have to have certain rules that express the dining preferences of that crowd. "No shoes, no shirt, no service" is a condition of use that expresses these preferences. If you want to be served, you have to be wearing shoes and a shirt.
In order to cater to a target ridership, the owners of public transportation services (whether they be public officials or private entrepreneurs) should be free to lay down conditions of use that express the riding preferences of that crowd. If a significant portion of the target ridership happen to be very socially conservative (as many working-class people are), then they might want to and should be free to take that social conservatism into account.
When I was taking summer classes at Cal, I drove to Fremont and took BART to downtown Berkeley. One day (I forgot whether it was the morning or afternoon) a woman and her 2-year-old daughter got on and sat right across from me. The girl was making a lot of noise, the mom was speaking to her in some Central or Eastern European language, and suddenly the girl was quiet. I looked up from my book, and saw that this woman was nursing her daughter (who was old enough to talk) on this train. They didn't hide it with a towel or anything.
Now, I didn't mind at all. If you want to nurse your kid right in front of me, you have my blessing. But you might not have the blessing of the other people on the bus or train. Luckily for her no one reacted with horror, and I doubt anyone would in the Bay Area. Even if people did dislike it, it would have to be a chronic "problem" and the number of people offended by it would have to be sufficiently large for any drop in business to be noticed.
If there are enough people who are offended by it, and if there are enough women who insist on nursing or pumping in transit, then the train or bus company can solve the problem by designating nursing cars or walled-off nursing sections in cars. Likewise, if there are enough people who are offended by nudity, and if there are enough people who insist on traveling nude, then the train or bus company can solve the problem by designating clothing-optional cars and buses. So long as people get on the proper car or bus, no one would be made a captive audience to the offending exposure.
Many urban areas in the U.S. are seeing a sharp increase in the number of conservative Muslim immigrants. Some of these women find it more appropriate to not be in any situation where their bodies are pressed against the bodies of men they aren't married to, and they would be very reluctant to get on a crowded car or bus. As of now, there aren't enough of them to make an impact, and women who prefer to not be touched by strange men just somehow make do. If transportation services in the U.S. want to cater to these women in the future, when the number of them might be drastically higher than it is now, they might want to consider designating women-and-children-only cars and buses, or women-and-children-only sections of cars and buses.
Before you spout off screaming "Segregation!", let me point out that we already have restrooms segregated by sex. Most women prefer to have a restroom experience that is free of men, and in response to this overall preference shopping malls, restaurants, train stations, and office buildings provide restrooms reserved only for women. No normal person would say that the women are discriminated against for having restrooms reserved specifically for them, or that men are discriminated against for not being allowed to use restrooms that women use.
And don't worry about this being some kind of special priviledge. It's just that in the near future there's going to be a large number of people who want a particular kind of service, just as there are large numbers of people today who want particular kinds of service, and if you can make a buck providing that kind of service then why not? So long as no one's assaulted, defrauded, burgled, or in some other way deprived of their sovereignty over themselves, the provision of special services is completely legitimate.
Another possible objection to women-only cars and buses can come from people who are bothered by social heterogeneity. If a society is to be stable, they say, then it must run on values that are shared by everyone, and allowing separate cars for women out of consideration for conservative muslim immigrants allows pockets of recent immigrants to exist as third-world peoples in an otherwise modern America. Now, whatever America's values are, social homogeneity shouldn't be one of them. We should be a people who tolerate experimentation - not just in technology, but also in ways of relating to each other. The fact that some people wear more clothes than you do, or separate themselves from the opposite gender more than you do, should be no political concern of yours. We pride ourselves in our freedom to live by the values we choose, and we even like to pretend that our nation was founded on that freedom. If other people value the segregation of sexes, then let them live according to that value. They don't violate your liberty by getting on their own train cars.
Did you ever wonder why there are a million different kinds of churches in America? It's because here we're relatively free to live according to the values we choose, so long as we allow others the same freedom. One of the main rules in "doing church" in America has been: If you don't like our rules, start your own church. And so for the past couple hundred years people have associated according to their shared ideas of what's right. We don't have an established church. No one's forced to go to any particular kind of church. We don't force everyone to adhere to the same church polity, listen to the same religious music, or keep the same dress code. If that's the freedom we're allowed in religion, why shouldn't we be allowed it in mass transit?
My radical proposal is this: allow people to choose their own rules. If they don't want naked guys on their buses, let them keep naked guys from getting on. If they want to be naked on the bus, let them have buses where they can be naked. If women want to go topless, they can get on the naked buses too. If women don't want to be touched by men they don't know, let them have women-only buses. This isn't an issue of what's appropriate in public. It's an issue of what preferences people have. And if this is to be a free country, entrepreneurs should be allowed to cater to different people's preferences.
This is a city bus - it's supposed to be for everybody who either can't or doesn't want to ride in a car or ride a bike. And we know that, in freer societies like ours, we're supposed to be free to do with ourselves as we please. Is it okay to kick him off the bus, or to not allow him on the bus in the first place? In some cases, yes. But wouldn't that violate his sovereignty over himself? I don't think so.
You should be free to walk around your own bedroom and bathroom naked. If your curtains are drawn, you should be free to walk around your entire house completely naked. If your neighbors permit, you should be free to walk around their house completely naked. If the owner of a restaurant permits, you should be perfectly free to sit at a table and enjoy a meal completely naked. You do not, however, have the right to present yourself unclothed on the property of anyone who doesn't consent to your nudity. You have sovereignty over yourself and what is yours; you do not have sovereignty over other people and their property.
We see the signs in restaurants that say "No shoes, no shirt, no service", and we never think twice about whether excluding someone who isn't properly clothed according to that sign violates those people's rights. Restaurant owners want to maintain a certain atmosphere that caters to a particular segment of the population (those who don't want to be offended by the presence of shirtless people), and to run their business the way they want to run it (which they have a right to) they have to make clear certain rules about how they want their property used. When a shirtless man walks in, no one violates his rights by refusing to take his order. If he really wants to have a shirtless restaurant experience, he could go to a restaurant that caters to people who don't mind the presence of shirtless patrons.
So, if a naked man gets on a bus where nudity is forbidden by the owner, the driver has every right to keep him from getting on. The only problem with applying this line of reasoning to city buses is that city buses belong to "the city" and not anyone in particular. But that isn't a problem with this line of reasoning. That's a problem with the oxymoronic idea of "public" ownership. Things that are publicly owned are supposedly owned and run by everybody for everybody. But we know that "public" services are funded by one segment of society (not everybody), distributed by another segment of society (again, not everybody) for the benefit of a very select segment of society (again, not everybody).
But I think I can address the problem of dress standards on public transportation without opining that tax subsidies for public transportation violate individuals' property rights, or that the most efficient mass transit is private mass transit.
As I wrote above, the restaurant managers want to cater to a certain crowd, and to do that they have to have certain rules that express the dining preferences of that crowd. "No shoes, no shirt, no service" is a condition of use that expresses these preferences. If you want to be served, you have to be wearing shoes and a shirt.
In order to cater to a target ridership, the owners of public transportation services (whether they be public officials or private entrepreneurs) should be free to lay down conditions of use that express the riding preferences of that crowd. If a significant portion of the target ridership happen to be very socially conservative (as many working-class people are), then they might want to and should be free to take that social conservatism into account.
When I was taking summer classes at Cal, I drove to Fremont and took BART to downtown Berkeley. One day (I forgot whether it was the morning or afternoon) a woman and her 2-year-old daughter got on and sat right across from me. The girl was making a lot of noise, the mom was speaking to her in some Central or Eastern European language, and suddenly the girl was quiet. I looked up from my book, and saw that this woman was nursing her daughter (who was old enough to talk) on this train. They didn't hide it with a towel or anything.
Now, I didn't mind at all. If you want to nurse your kid right in front of me, you have my blessing. But you might not have the blessing of the other people on the bus or train. Luckily for her no one reacted with horror, and I doubt anyone would in the Bay Area. Even if people did dislike it, it would have to be a chronic "problem" and the number of people offended by it would have to be sufficiently large for any drop in business to be noticed.
If there are enough people who are offended by it, and if there are enough women who insist on nursing or pumping in transit, then the train or bus company can solve the problem by designating nursing cars or walled-off nursing sections in cars. Likewise, if there are enough people who are offended by nudity, and if there are enough people who insist on traveling nude, then the train or bus company can solve the problem by designating clothing-optional cars and buses. So long as people get on the proper car or bus, no one would be made a captive audience to the offending exposure.
Many urban areas in the U.S. are seeing a sharp increase in the number of conservative Muslim immigrants. Some of these women find it more appropriate to not be in any situation where their bodies are pressed against the bodies of men they aren't married to, and they would be very reluctant to get on a crowded car or bus. As of now, there aren't enough of them to make an impact, and women who prefer to not be touched by strange men just somehow make do. If transportation services in the U.S. want to cater to these women in the future, when the number of them might be drastically higher than it is now, they might want to consider designating women-and-children-only cars and buses, or women-and-children-only sections of cars and buses.
Before you spout off screaming "Segregation!", let me point out that we already have restrooms segregated by sex. Most women prefer to have a restroom experience that is free of men, and in response to this overall preference shopping malls, restaurants, train stations, and office buildings provide restrooms reserved only for women. No normal person would say that the women are discriminated against for having restrooms reserved specifically for them, or that men are discriminated against for not being allowed to use restrooms that women use.
And don't worry about this being some kind of special priviledge. It's just that in the near future there's going to be a large number of people who want a particular kind of service, just as there are large numbers of people today who want particular kinds of service, and if you can make a buck providing that kind of service then why not? So long as no one's assaulted, defrauded, burgled, or in some other way deprived of their sovereignty over themselves, the provision of special services is completely legitimate.
Another possible objection to women-only cars and buses can come from people who are bothered by social heterogeneity. If a society is to be stable, they say, then it must run on values that are shared by everyone, and allowing separate cars for women out of consideration for conservative muslim immigrants allows pockets of recent immigrants to exist as third-world peoples in an otherwise modern America. Now, whatever America's values are, social homogeneity shouldn't be one of them. We should be a people who tolerate experimentation - not just in technology, but also in ways of relating to each other. The fact that some people wear more clothes than you do, or separate themselves from the opposite gender more than you do, should be no political concern of yours. We pride ourselves in our freedom to live by the values we choose, and we even like to pretend that our nation was founded on that freedom. If other people value the segregation of sexes, then let them live according to that value. They don't violate your liberty by getting on their own train cars.
Did you ever wonder why there are a million different kinds of churches in America? It's because here we're relatively free to live according to the values we choose, so long as we allow others the same freedom. One of the main rules in "doing church" in America has been: If you don't like our rules, start your own church. And so for the past couple hundred years people have associated according to their shared ideas of what's right. We don't have an established church. No one's forced to go to any particular kind of church. We don't force everyone to adhere to the same church polity, listen to the same religious music, or keep the same dress code. If that's the freedom we're allowed in religion, why shouldn't we be allowed it in mass transit?
My radical proposal is this: allow people to choose their own rules. If they don't want naked guys on their buses, let them keep naked guys from getting on. If they want to be naked on the bus, let them have buses where they can be naked. If women want to go topless, they can get on the naked buses too. If women don't want to be touched by men they don't know, let them have women-only buses. This isn't an issue of what's appropriate in public. It's an issue of what preferences people have. And if this is to be a free country, entrepreneurs should be allowed to cater to different people's preferences.
Wednesday, August 26, 2009
Individualism
In matters of politics and social morality, I consider myself a "purified individualist". Now, by individualist, I don't mean long bangs and skinny jeans and music with unpredictable tempo changes and disorienting time signatures. I don't mean intentionally acting in ways that other people find distasteful. I don't mean crossdressing for the sake of insulting someone's sense of gender-appropriateness. Though some of you might think of me when you hear of things like that, that's not what I mean when I say my political ideology is Individualism.
By "Individualism", I mean that radical idea that you don't own other people, that you have no right to do anything to them that they don't want done, take anything from them that they don't want to give, or threaten to do any of those things, so long as they're not intruding into someone else's matters. Think of it this way: Every man is his own king, with absolute sovereignty over his own life (and every woman is her own queen, etc.). Sure, it means that if a guy wants to wear a dress just so he could insult other peoples' sense of gender-appropriateness, then you have to let him do it (unless of course, he's violating someone's property rights while he's at it). But that's all that it means. It doesn't mean that you have to act so different that other people say "omg, you're such an individual."
In his essay on Henry David Thoreau, Randall Conrad wrote "Despite his deep-rooted individualism, Thoreau was readily moved to activism against injustice." Randall's use of the word "individualism" doesn't match the way I use it. Randall uses it as if it means isolationism. Now there is a type of foreign policy called "isolationism", which people like me are accused of advocating, but isolationism isn't what's implied by individualism. Isolationism means you have to keep to yourself, and have minimal interaction with others (or stay in your own country, and have minimal interaction with foreigners); Individualism means you have no right to initiate force against another. According to Individualism, you have every right to intervene to stop injustice. You just don't have the right to force other people to help you do it. You could encourage others to help you, but threatening force against nonparticipants isn't the correct way to do it.
Sure, fight your wars of liberation. But
1. Don't kill civilians (that's murder);
2. Don't force other people to pay for it (that's robbery); and
3. Don't force other people to fight your wars for you (that's slavery).
So when you tell me that so-n-so's an individualist like me, you better not be talking about his predisposition to disagree with people, or about some weird diet he's trying (unless it's out of consideration for human or animal rights).
On a less serious note, my second nephew "arrived" yesterday. It wasn't as if he wasn't already here, though. When my sister visited last month it was kinda hard to ignore the fact that there was a baby inside her. And since it was inside her, where else could it have been but right here? Oh well. Since little Jordan was born yesterday, people will celebrate the beginning of his life on August 25th. I, however, will celebrate the beginning of my life in the month that it really began - November.
When I say I espouse "purified individualism", I mean that I believe individual rights don't depend on how drastically you can affect the world around you. They don't depend on what you've contributed, how strong you are, how smart you are, how many people you know, or any of that. They don't depend on your physical or mental capacities or state of development. If you have rights as an individual, then your rights don't depend on how others value you. They don't depend on your race, mother tongue, species, or age. You have them whether you're an adult human, a fetus, or an animal... I constantly strive to purge from my ethical framework all forms of anti-individualism, from utilitarianism to is-ought-ism. That's why I say "purified individualism".
By "Individualism", I mean that radical idea that you don't own other people, that you have no right to do anything to them that they don't want done, take anything from them that they don't want to give, or threaten to do any of those things, so long as they're not intruding into someone else's matters. Think of it this way: Every man is his own king, with absolute sovereignty over his own life (and every woman is her own queen, etc.). Sure, it means that if a guy wants to wear a dress just so he could insult other peoples' sense of gender-appropriateness, then you have to let him do it (unless of course, he's violating someone's property rights while he's at it). But that's all that it means. It doesn't mean that you have to act so different that other people say "omg, you're such an individual."
In his essay on Henry David Thoreau, Randall Conrad wrote "Despite his deep-rooted individualism, Thoreau was readily moved to activism against injustice." Randall's use of the word "individualism" doesn't match the way I use it. Randall uses it as if it means isolationism. Now there is a type of foreign policy called "isolationism", which people like me are accused of advocating, but isolationism isn't what's implied by individualism. Isolationism means you have to keep to yourself, and have minimal interaction with others (or stay in your own country, and have minimal interaction with foreigners); Individualism means you have no right to initiate force against another. According to Individualism, you have every right to intervene to stop injustice. You just don't have the right to force other people to help you do it. You could encourage others to help you, but threatening force against nonparticipants isn't the correct way to do it.
Sure, fight your wars of liberation. But
1. Don't kill civilians (that's murder);
2. Don't force other people to pay for it (that's robbery); and
3. Don't force other people to fight your wars for you (that's slavery).
So when you tell me that so-n-so's an individualist like me, you better not be talking about his predisposition to disagree with people, or about some weird diet he's trying (unless it's out of consideration for human or animal rights).
On a less serious note, my second nephew "arrived" yesterday. It wasn't as if he wasn't already here, though. When my sister visited last month it was kinda hard to ignore the fact that there was a baby inside her. And since it was inside her, where else could it have been but right here? Oh well. Since little Jordan was born yesterday, people will celebrate the beginning of his life on August 25th. I, however, will celebrate the beginning of my life in the month that it really began - November.
When I say I espouse "purified individualism", I mean that I believe individual rights don't depend on how drastically you can affect the world around you. They don't depend on what you've contributed, how strong you are, how smart you are, how many people you know, or any of that. They don't depend on your physical or mental capacities or state of development. If you have rights as an individual, then your rights don't depend on how others value you. They don't depend on your race, mother tongue, species, or age. You have them whether you're an adult human, a fetus, or an animal... I constantly strive to purge from my ethical framework all forms of anti-individualism, from utilitarianism to is-ought-ism. That's why I say "purified individualism".
Monday, August 24, 2009
ONE OF MY -ISM PRISMS
The conventional spectrum for political viewpoints doesn't make much sense.
Conservatives hate big government, supposedly. But they love taxes, subsidies, centralization, and regulation when it comes to the military and "national security". They don't want the government telling us what medicine to take, but they do want the government to tell us what drugs are too dangerous to take, and they think the government isn't throwing enough people in prison for taking or selling the dangerous drugs.
Liberals supposedly think we should be free to put whatever we want into our bodies. But they too want to protect us from the dangerous drugs, and so they want all sorts of regulation in place - God forbid we be allowed to take the wrong medicine. They oppose the wasteful military-industrial complex, but they just love the medical-industrial complex, and they want to expand it even more.
Sticking "Conservatives" on the Right and "Liberals" on the Left really doesn't help us map things out. Probably the most important question to ask when mapping out political beliefs is this: Who owns your body? How people answer this question should determine where they fit on the spectrum.
If they answer "your parents" or "your family", then they go on the right end of this spectrum under "Family-ism". According to this view, the people you inherently owe duties to are the ones in your family. Your parents can assign you chores whether you like them or not, and how much your allowance will be or even whether or not you'll get one; they can decide when you'll work in the family store and whether you'll be paid; they can demand that you accomodate them in your house when they get old and that you wipe them up after they make a mess in their bed; etc. They can decide what type of medical treatment you get, and no one else, not you, not the neighbors, and definitely not the government, can decide that for you; they can decide what kind of education, if any, you'll get, and again, no one else, not you, not the neighbors, and definitely not the government, can decide that; they can decide whether and how severely and by what methods you'll be disciplined; etc.
Just to the left of this kind of Family-ism is Extended Family-ism. Think of the Samoan girls who can't go out without getting permission not just from their parents but also from their siblings and uncles and aunts and grandparents. And you can think of my dad spanking my cousin for kicking my grandpa and yelling "Get out Fatso!"
To the left of that is Tribalism. According to this view, your most weighty inherent duties are not to your family or extended family, but to a larger class of people that you're somehow related to. There's one other trait that most other -isms have, but which I'll bring up here - the collective person. I could have brought it up under Family-ism. When the stolen gold and clothes were found in Achan's tent, he and his whole family were stoned to death. They all collectively shared the responsibility for his wrongdoing. But we usually think of tribalist feuds when we think of random people being punished for the sins of other members of their group.
When the tribe is defined in terms of a monopoly of violence, it's called a "nation". According to Nationalism, you owe your most valuable inherent duties not to your family, church, or ethnicity, but to that enterprise that holds the monopoly of violence over the geographic area you happen to be in. You ultimately belong to the State. It is the State (or, in American English, "the government") that dictates how long you'll work and what job you're permitted to work, how much money you'll be paid, how much money you'll give where, by what procedure you can become a member of the State, and whether you'll go to war. All members of the State are members of one collective person, all belonging mutually to each other, as if they all were married in one gigantic polygamous wedding when they were born (or when they were naturalized).
I wrote earlier that war is just a really big drive-by shooting. It's also a really big tribal feud. Since the members of the Nation are just body parts of the same collective person, individuals can be knocked off for their government's wrongdoing. Civilian deaths really aren't murder, according to Nationalism, because the civilians share their nation's guilt. Terrorism is wrong, not because innocent civilians are killed, but because they're killed by people who aren't owned by a Nation State.
"Conservatism" and "Liberalism" are really just different types of Nationalism. The stereotypical liberal thinks we should have unions and licensing to block out competition and protect the wages of American workers. The stereotypical conservative thinks we should have fences and cameras and armed guards along the border to make sure nobody "steals our jobs". They both want to use government intervention to dole out favors that wouldn't and couldn't be gotten through voluntary interaction. They both want a monopoly of violence to limit individual freedom for the benefit of the collective. They're both Socialist, because they're both Statist.
Up until the current recession, Nationalism was being outmoded by a more chic kind of collectivism - Internationalism. Why did we invade Iraq? Not just to protect America from the terrorists who weren't there yet, but also to liberate the Iraqi people from their tyrant. And why do we keep our troops out there in two unwinnable wars? Because our obligations to the Iraqi and Afghani people dictate that we continue spending American blood and American tax dollars in foreign lands. Nevermind the bridges, we got some liberating to do!
Not only do we have enforceable obligations to fund the Iraqi and Afghani war efforts, we also have the enforceable obligation to fund the Israeli war effort. Because, after all, we belong not just to our own people and our own government, but also to the governments that our government has especially good relations with. So long as money is taken from us by force to build F-16s and tanks and missiles, some of those F-16s and tanks and missiles will go to the State of Israel for their seasonal games.
Foaming-at-the-mouth Neocon "patriots" aren't the only ones who want U.S. troops and tax dollars spent abroad. You can probably think of some genocide somewhere that some "progressive" wants the U.S. military to stop. But the military isn't the only tool in their box. They also want us to send more food, more investment in their underdeveloped markets, more subsidies for their infrastructure, more oversight of their elections, more AIDS medicine, and many more types of foreign aide that'll be lost in bureaucracy - basically, more hand-outs to corrupt governments - all wrung from our noses by threats of imprisonment and deprivation.
Internationalism is just a more leftist kind of Nationalism. And in some cases, it leads to an international State. Think of the European Union. The Brit doesn't owe large sums of his money only to his compatriots for their healthcare and education; now, he owes something to just about everybody in an EU-member country. He doesn't just have to obey the regulations dictated by Parliament; now he has to worry about the dictates of Brussels.
The central idea of Internationalism is that we are a collective person with people who are not part of our Nation, that we owe foreigners the same supposed duties we owe our compatriots, that whatever it takes to give foreigners a decent life can rightfully be taken from us by force, that we have the authority to take control of foreign countries - basically, that we belong to foreigners and that foreigners belong to us. The logical consequence of this is Globalism - the rank leftist idea that everybody in the whole world belongs to everybody in the whole world. Whatever it takes to give everybody in the whole world a decent life can be taken from everybody in the whole world by threat of force. Naturally, the solution to all the problems in the whole world is one world government.
So there you have it. The better political spectrum shows family-ism on the right, where individuals are owned by their families, Nationalism in the middle, where individuals are owned by the Nation State, and Globalism on the far left, where everybody is owned by everybody.
You'll notice that the further left you go on the spectrum, the less voluntary (or rather, the more involuntary) the ownership relation. If you hate your parents, you could theoretically disown them. If you don't like your country, you could expatriate. It would be really hard to, but it's possible if you're rich enough. If you don't like the world, though, well that's gonna be hard to run away from.
Also, the further left the ownership relation, the less control you have over the decision-making process. Just think of it this way - the bigger the body of people, the more diluted your voice is. Democracy can "work" in a city-state or a commune; it can't work in a nation-state or a world government, since people have virtually no say in what goes on.
And, the bigger the body of people, the bigger their administrative body will have to be, meaning that more resources would be soaked upward through that pyramid scheme called "government".
Secessionists, devolutionists, and others who believe in decentralization lean towards the right of this spectrum. Some of them want more powers to be transferred from the Federal government to the States. Some of them want the states in their region to secede completely and be their own country. Some of them go further. When they say "small government", they really mean small government - small like The Free and Sovereign City of Santa Clara type small. Then there's me.
I really don't fit anywhere on this spectrum. If you were to try to place me, you'd have to put me off to the right of it. I don't think the individual is owned by anybody. No one is entitled to any inherent duties from the individual, not even the parents. Whatever rights the parents have over their kids are very, very limited. And government has absolutely no rights over children. No one has inherent authority over another. Not family, not government, not international peace-keeping organizations.
I admit it, this spectrum is still a spectrum, and so it only works on an issue-by-issue basis. Typical conservatives are Familyist in most private matters, Nationalist when it comes to abortion, Internationalist when it comes to military defense, and Familyist when it comes to economic matters besides immigration, in which they are Nationalist. Typical liberals are Nationalist when it comes to the family, except for abortion, in which most of them are Familyist (the unborn fetus is property to be disposed of by the mother) (though some of them are Nationalist or even Internationalist in that they think government programs to encourage aborting unwanted fetuses would work towards the common good), Nationalist when it comes to health insurance, Nationalist or Internationalist when it comes to the economy and finance, and Internationalist when it comes to military defense and the environment.
Also, the result it gives depends on how you define the individual. By my definition, the pro-choice libertarian isn't an Individualist, but a Familyist. But by the pro-choice libertarian's definition, she would be an Individualist and I would be the Familyist/Tribalist/Nationalist/some other kind of anti-individualist.
Another political spectrum would be useful. Rather than ask "Who owns you?" it could ask "What is sovereign?" That would have to be the topic of another post.
Conservatives hate big government, supposedly. But they love taxes, subsidies, centralization, and regulation when it comes to the military and "national security". They don't want the government telling us what medicine to take, but they do want the government to tell us what drugs are too dangerous to take, and they think the government isn't throwing enough people in prison for taking or selling the dangerous drugs.
Liberals supposedly think we should be free to put whatever we want into our bodies. But they too want to protect us from the dangerous drugs, and so they want all sorts of regulation in place - God forbid we be allowed to take the wrong medicine. They oppose the wasteful military-industrial complex, but they just love the medical-industrial complex, and they want to expand it even more.
Sticking "Conservatives" on the Right and "Liberals" on the Left really doesn't help us map things out. Probably the most important question to ask when mapping out political beliefs is this: Who owns your body? How people answer this question should determine where they fit on the spectrum.
If they answer "your parents" or "your family", then they go on the right end of this spectrum under "Family-ism". According to this view, the people you inherently owe duties to are the ones in your family. Your parents can assign you chores whether you like them or not, and how much your allowance will be or even whether or not you'll get one; they can decide when you'll work in the family store and whether you'll be paid; they can demand that you accomodate them in your house when they get old and that you wipe them up after they make a mess in their bed; etc. They can decide what type of medical treatment you get, and no one else, not you, not the neighbors, and definitely not the government, can decide that for you; they can decide what kind of education, if any, you'll get, and again, no one else, not you, not the neighbors, and definitely not the government, can decide that; they can decide whether and how severely and by what methods you'll be disciplined; etc.
Just to the left of this kind of Family-ism is Extended Family-ism. Think of the Samoan girls who can't go out without getting permission not just from their parents but also from their siblings and uncles and aunts and grandparents. And you can think of my dad spanking my cousin for kicking my grandpa and yelling "Get out Fatso!"
To the left of that is Tribalism. According to this view, your most weighty inherent duties are not to your family or extended family, but to a larger class of people that you're somehow related to. There's one other trait that most other -isms have, but which I'll bring up here - the collective person. I could have brought it up under Family-ism. When the stolen gold and clothes were found in Achan's tent, he and his whole family were stoned to death. They all collectively shared the responsibility for his wrongdoing. But we usually think of tribalist feuds when we think of random people being punished for the sins of other members of their group.
When the tribe is defined in terms of a monopoly of violence, it's called a "nation". According to Nationalism, you owe your most valuable inherent duties not to your family, church, or ethnicity, but to that enterprise that holds the monopoly of violence over the geographic area you happen to be in. You ultimately belong to the State. It is the State (or, in American English, "the government") that dictates how long you'll work and what job you're permitted to work, how much money you'll be paid, how much money you'll give where, by what procedure you can become a member of the State, and whether you'll go to war. All members of the State are members of one collective person, all belonging mutually to each other, as if they all were married in one gigantic polygamous wedding when they were born (or when they were naturalized).
I wrote earlier that war is just a really big drive-by shooting. It's also a really big tribal feud. Since the members of the Nation are just body parts of the same collective person, individuals can be knocked off for their government's wrongdoing. Civilian deaths really aren't murder, according to Nationalism, because the civilians share their nation's guilt. Terrorism is wrong, not because innocent civilians are killed, but because they're killed by people who aren't owned by a Nation State.
"Conservatism" and "Liberalism" are really just different types of Nationalism. The stereotypical liberal thinks we should have unions and licensing to block out competition and protect the wages of American workers. The stereotypical conservative thinks we should have fences and cameras and armed guards along the border to make sure nobody "steals our jobs". They both want to use government intervention to dole out favors that wouldn't and couldn't be gotten through voluntary interaction. They both want a monopoly of violence to limit individual freedom for the benefit of the collective. They're both Socialist, because they're both Statist.
Up until the current recession, Nationalism was being outmoded by a more chic kind of collectivism - Internationalism. Why did we invade Iraq? Not just to protect America from the terrorists who weren't there yet, but also to liberate the Iraqi people from their tyrant. And why do we keep our troops out there in two unwinnable wars? Because our obligations to the Iraqi and Afghani people dictate that we continue spending American blood and American tax dollars in foreign lands. Nevermind the bridges, we got some liberating to do!
Not only do we have enforceable obligations to fund the Iraqi and Afghani war efforts, we also have the enforceable obligation to fund the Israeli war effort. Because, after all, we belong not just to our own people and our own government, but also to the governments that our government has especially good relations with. So long as money is taken from us by force to build F-16s and tanks and missiles, some of those F-16s and tanks and missiles will go to the State of Israel for their seasonal games.
Foaming-at-the-mouth Neocon "patriots" aren't the only ones who want U.S. troops and tax dollars spent abroad. You can probably think of some genocide somewhere that some "progressive" wants the U.S. military to stop. But the military isn't the only tool in their box. They also want us to send more food, more investment in their underdeveloped markets, more subsidies for their infrastructure, more oversight of their elections, more AIDS medicine, and many more types of foreign aide that'll be lost in bureaucracy - basically, more hand-outs to corrupt governments - all wrung from our noses by threats of imprisonment and deprivation.
Internationalism is just a more leftist kind of Nationalism. And in some cases, it leads to an international State. Think of the European Union. The Brit doesn't owe large sums of his money only to his compatriots for their healthcare and education; now, he owes something to just about everybody in an EU-member country. He doesn't just have to obey the regulations dictated by Parliament; now he has to worry about the dictates of Brussels.
The central idea of Internationalism is that we are a collective person with people who are not part of our Nation, that we owe foreigners the same supposed duties we owe our compatriots, that whatever it takes to give foreigners a decent life can rightfully be taken from us by force, that we have the authority to take control of foreign countries - basically, that we belong to foreigners and that foreigners belong to us. The logical consequence of this is Globalism - the rank leftist idea that everybody in the whole world belongs to everybody in the whole world. Whatever it takes to give everybody in the whole world a decent life can be taken from everybody in the whole world by threat of force. Naturally, the solution to all the problems in the whole world is one world government.
So there you have it. The better political spectrum shows family-ism on the right, where individuals are owned by their families, Nationalism in the middle, where individuals are owned by the Nation State, and Globalism on the far left, where everybody is owned by everybody.
You'll notice that the further left you go on the spectrum, the less voluntary (or rather, the more involuntary) the ownership relation. If you hate your parents, you could theoretically disown them. If you don't like your country, you could expatriate. It would be really hard to, but it's possible if you're rich enough. If you don't like the world, though, well that's gonna be hard to run away from.
Also, the further left the ownership relation, the less control you have over the decision-making process. Just think of it this way - the bigger the body of people, the more diluted your voice is. Democracy can "work" in a city-state or a commune; it can't work in a nation-state or a world government, since people have virtually no say in what goes on.
And, the bigger the body of people, the bigger their administrative body will have to be, meaning that more resources would be soaked upward through that pyramid scheme called "government".
Secessionists, devolutionists, and others who believe in decentralization lean towards the right of this spectrum. Some of them want more powers to be transferred from the Federal government to the States. Some of them want the states in their region to secede completely and be their own country. Some of them go further. When they say "small government", they really mean small government - small like The Free and Sovereign City of Santa Clara type small. Then there's me.
I really don't fit anywhere on this spectrum. If you were to try to place me, you'd have to put me off to the right of it. I don't think the individual is owned by anybody. No one is entitled to any inherent duties from the individual, not even the parents. Whatever rights the parents have over their kids are very, very limited. And government has absolutely no rights over children. No one has inherent authority over another. Not family, not government, not international peace-keeping organizations.
I admit it, this spectrum is still a spectrum, and so it only works on an issue-by-issue basis. Typical conservatives are Familyist in most private matters, Nationalist when it comes to abortion, Internationalist when it comes to military defense, and Familyist when it comes to economic matters besides immigration, in which they are Nationalist. Typical liberals are Nationalist when it comes to the family, except for abortion, in which most of them are Familyist (the unborn fetus is property to be disposed of by the mother) (though some of them are Nationalist or even Internationalist in that they think government programs to encourage aborting unwanted fetuses would work towards the common good), Nationalist when it comes to health insurance, Nationalist or Internationalist when it comes to the economy and finance, and Internationalist when it comes to military defense and the environment.
Also, the result it gives depends on how you define the individual. By my definition, the pro-choice libertarian isn't an Individualist, but a Familyist. But by the pro-choice libertarian's definition, she would be an Individualist and I would be the Familyist/Tribalist/Nationalist/some other kind of anti-individualist.
Another political spectrum would be useful. Rather than ask "Who owns you?" it could ask "What is sovereign?" That would have to be the topic of another post.
Wednesday, August 19, 2009
Sex and Right, Part 3
There are two opposing and equally insufficient ways to get morality: one is egoism, the other altruism. Moral egoism is the view that what is right to do is whatever one thinks is best for oneself. The well-being of others is relevant only so long as it secures one's own well-being. I have a few things to say about this view, but you'll have to wait for my next Sex and Right post to read them. For now, let's look at moral altruism.
Moral altruism is the view that every individual has the inherrent (that is, you have it whether you want it or not), moral obligation to live for others. This isn't the negative obligation to refrain from hurting other people and damaging their property. It's the positive obligation to actively help people to live comfortably. Now, if you think you do have that obligation, I have no problem with you living completely for others. You even have my respect. But most altruists go further than living entirely for others.
To the most egalitarian altruists, the obligation to live for others is an enforceable obligation. Not only do you have to pay for the education of kids you've never seen before - if you don't, the amount of money you owe "society" gets taken away from you. And if you try to resist, you get treated as if you were the one stealing. This is the chic ideology preached from all our pulpits, from White House youtube ads to "Town Hall Meentings" and press conferences on C-SPAN to really bad t-shirts in the mall.
Let's look deeper at this kind of altruism, and see what its logical consequences are.
When they say we have to work for the benefit of others, what do they mean when they say "benefit"? Well, no one can ever talk about a benefit without talking about something that increases someone's happiness. When we talk about the benefits of contemporary life, we're really talking about the level of comfort we have - the amount of free time we have, the quantity, intensity, and accessibility of leisure, the spaciousness of our homes (and whether we have homes), cleanliness, the abundance and variety of food, and the absence of unpleasantries such as physical abuse, extreme social tension, and disease. So altruism is really the view that we all have the inherent, enforceable positive obligation to make other people happy. Since this obligation is enforceable, other people are entitled to force us to make them happy.
(Now, if the purpose of my life is the other guy's happiness, then I don't see what's so wrong with just working for my own happiness. But I digress...)
We're forced to provide housing for those who cannot afford it on their own. We're forced to buy food - through food stamps - for people who cannot feed their whole family. If a man can't afford to send his kid to school, we pay for the education for him. And when his kid is done with school, we send him to college. And we're forced to do it. (And we're forced to fund the rich man's war.) We're compelled to meet such a variety of physical and mental needs, I'm surprised sex isn't one of those needs.
Who's to say sex isn't one of those needs? Very few people live their entire lives celibate. Just look at how many people around you have sex or used to regularly have sex. It's something we're wired to want. And people live much more comfortably when they have a fulfilling sexual outlet. An imam in Iran was griping about women's clothing, and said that once he soiled himself in the car when he passed a woman on the street who wasn't properly covered. That's what happens when men neglect their physical needs.
Since sex is a need just like housing and food, why not mandate the provision of sex? Men have to register for compulsory military service - why not have women register for compulsory sexual service? It'll be all for the greater good. People who don't have access to basic services like food and housing go and steal to meet their needs. Men who don't have access to the baser services are going to rape or do some other ridiculous thing to meet that need.
Think compulsory sexual service is too extreme? Well then, instead of having a draft, we can change our sex reform to merely prohibit discrimination in sexual matters. No longer should people be free to discriminate by body type, facial structure, personality, or odor. You unjustly deny people's right to a full and happy life when you deny access according to physical traits.
This all sounds absurd, and rightly so. A woman's body is her temple, and trespassing on it is sacrilege. Her body is hers and only hers. No one else is entitled to it without her permission. (My views on abortion and a few other things can be found here.)
Now, if no one is entitled to a woman's body without her permission, why are other people entitled to the fruit of a woman's labor without her permission? By what authority can an agency (the government) dictate that such and such proportion of a woman's income is due to other people? Doesn't that sound like slavery?
The altruism that leftists preach amounts to institutionalized rape. It demands that we be forced to do things to make other people happy, as if other people are entitled to our bodies. If any one word can describe this, it's RAPE.
Here's an especially American kind of sex "reform". Instead of having a cumbersome sex draft, just have an adult entertainment licensing program that requires each adult film actress who wants a license to do a film every other year to be broadcast on a public tv channel, maybe C-SPAN X. And you can legalize prostitution and regulate it with a licensing program that has a pro bono quota. And the anti-discrimination law I mentioned above is an essential part of any American "reform"...
Moral altruism is the view that every individual has the inherrent (that is, you have it whether you want it or not), moral obligation to live for others. This isn't the negative obligation to refrain from hurting other people and damaging their property. It's the positive obligation to actively help people to live comfortably. Now, if you think you do have that obligation, I have no problem with you living completely for others. You even have my respect. But most altruists go further than living entirely for others.
To the most egalitarian altruists, the obligation to live for others is an enforceable obligation. Not only do you have to pay for the education of kids you've never seen before - if you don't, the amount of money you owe "society" gets taken away from you. And if you try to resist, you get treated as if you were the one stealing. This is the chic ideology preached from all our pulpits, from White House youtube ads to "Town Hall Meentings" and press conferences on C-SPAN to really bad t-shirts in the mall.
Let's look deeper at this kind of altruism, and see what its logical consequences are.
When they say we have to work for the benefit of others, what do they mean when they say "benefit"? Well, no one can ever talk about a benefit without talking about something that increases someone's happiness. When we talk about the benefits of contemporary life, we're really talking about the level of comfort we have - the amount of free time we have, the quantity, intensity, and accessibility of leisure, the spaciousness of our homes (and whether we have homes), cleanliness, the abundance and variety of food, and the absence of unpleasantries such as physical abuse, extreme social tension, and disease. So altruism is really the view that we all have the inherent, enforceable positive obligation to make other people happy. Since this obligation is enforceable, other people are entitled to force us to make them happy.
(Now, if the purpose of my life is the other guy's happiness, then I don't see what's so wrong with just working for my own happiness. But I digress...)
We're forced to provide housing for those who cannot afford it on their own. We're forced to buy food - through food stamps - for people who cannot feed their whole family. If a man can't afford to send his kid to school, we pay for the education for him. And when his kid is done with school, we send him to college. And we're forced to do it. (And we're forced to fund the rich man's war.) We're compelled to meet such a variety of physical and mental needs, I'm surprised sex isn't one of those needs.
Who's to say sex isn't one of those needs? Very few people live their entire lives celibate. Just look at how many people around you have sex or used to regularly have sex. It's something we're wired to want. And people live much more comfortably when they have a fulfilling sexual outlet. An imam in Iran was griping about women's clothing, and said that once he soiled himself in the car when he passed a woman on the street who wasn't properly covered. That's what happens when men neglect their physical needs.
Since sex is a need just like housing and food, why not mandate the provision of sex? Men have to register for compulsory military service - why not have women register for compulsory sexual service? It'll be all for the greater good. People who don't have access to basic services like food and housing go and steal to meet their needs. Men who don't have access to the baser services are going to rape or do some other ridiculous thing to meet that need.
Think compulsory sexual service is too extreme? Well then, instead of having a draft, we can change our sex reform to merely prohibit discrimination in sexual matters. No longer should people be free to discriminate by body type, facial structure, personality, or odor. You unjustly deny people's right to a full and happy life when you deny access according to physical traits.
This all sounds absurd, and rightly so. A woman's body is her temple, and trespassing on it is sacrilege. Her body is hers and only hers. No one else is entitled to it without her permission. (My views on abortion and a few other things can be found here.)
Now, if no one is entitled to a woman's body without her permission, why are other people entitled to the fruit of a woman's labor without her permission? By what authority can an agency (the government) dictate that such and such proportion of a woman's income is due to other people? Doesn't that sound like slavery?
The altruism that leftists preach amounts to institutionalized rape. It demands that we be forced to do things to make other people happy, as if other people are entitled to our bodies. If any one word can describe this, it's RAPE.
Here's an especially American kind of sex "reform". Instead of having a cumbersome sex draft, just have an adult entertainment licensing program that requires each adult film actress who wants a license to do a film every other year to be broadcast on a public tv channel, maybe C-SPAN X. And you can legalize prostitution and regulate it with a licensing program that has a pro bono quota. And the anti-discrimination law I mentioned above is an essential part of any American "reform"...
Sunday, August 16, 2009
Church Report!
A book report is a "short" summary of a book you're supposed to have read. You might remember doing a few of those in elementary school. Today I'm going to do a church report. I'm going to give an overview of churches I've visited since I stopped attending my parents' church, and I'm going to say a few things I think of them.
I've already posted a video on what things I'm looking for in churches, but that wasn't really a report. I didn't say whether these churches actually have those things I'm looking for. That's what I'm going to do here.
The first church I visited was the Friends' Meeting in San Jose. I feel sorry that the one thing I've ever written about them was a little negative. So before I say what I'm going to, I must point out that the Quaker Church in San Jose is a charming little place that everyone should visit at least once. I should also say that the Quakers are generous enough to allow Santa Clara County Activists for Animals to use their building for free. I can't be grateful enough for that. They also have a potluck almost every Sunday.
Now, to say what I think of them as a church. I mentioned in my video that the first church to officially endorse universal healthcare is the first one I'll stop going to. The Quaker Church did just that when they passed a minute in their "Business Worship" calling for mandatory, federally-funded health coverage and expressing preference for a single-payer system.
Someone had contended in the previous business meeting that forcing people to get health coverage can be a violation of their conscience, so they postponed the decision for a month (business meetings are once a month). That person wasn't at this meeting, everyone knew she wouldn't be at the meeting, and they passed the minute without her. I could have raised my voice in opposition, but there were a few reasons I didn't. For one thing, I am not a "convinced" Quaker. Even though I am welcome to participate in the business meeting, and even though they wouldn't pass a measure if I oppose it, I feel very uncomfortable keeping them from saying something that 99% of them agree with. I also felt uncomfortable saying anything against it because just the previous business meeting I sternly told all of them that I oppose the use of lethal force against any sentient being on my behalf, and that they're going to have to figure out a way to deal with their gopher problem without killing any gophers. I hate to sound like the contrarian.
Another thing I should say about Quaker business meetings: the size of the church more than doubles - maybe quadruples - on business meeting days. Lots and lots of people show up only on the Sunday that they have the business meetings. There are other people who show up a little more often, but maybe every other Sunday. I didn't say this in my video, but that's not the type of attendance I want to see in a church. I really can't "do church" with people who I can't count on being there every week.
There is one other reason I will likely decide against making the Friends' Meeting my "home church". I don't have a Quaker temperament. I can't deal with keeping my eyes closed and sitting still in complete silence for a whole hour. I wasn't raised a Quaker. I was raised a Baptist. I need someone standing above me looking down at me telling me what I should and shouldn't do. And I need lots and lots of music.
Lots and lots of music (and someone telling me what to do) can be heard at St. Mark's Episcopal Church in Santa Clara. If you like hymns and organs, St. Mark's is a place you should visit. Also, there's an impressive diversity in the congregation - you can find just about any kind of person there, so long as they're white (or a black autistic kid adopted by a lesbian couple). But seriously, there are both conservatives and liberals in the church, and that would make a quasi-conservative like me quite happy.
As is common in Episcopal churches, the preacher is a white woman who talks as if she's everybody's mother. And her sermon dripped with the 3-letter G-word. If you could wring it out, it would still drip with that word.
Like the services of other noticeably Catholic denominations, the Episcopal service revolves around the Eucharist. And as in other noticeably Catholic denominations, the Eucharist is performed after everyone recites the Apostles' Creed or the Nicene Creed. Both these creeds declare belief in "God, the Father Almighty" who made the earth and everything on it. I already wrote a Facebook note entitled "Went to Church Today" where I explain my discomfort with this, but I'll write it here. If I take Communion after professing belief in the "Maker of all things visible and invisible", wouldn't I then be endorsing the food chain, and thus the subjugation of innumerable sentient beings? If God is not the creator of evil, then he cannot be the creator of the natural order.
The Episcopal church has Open Communion, meaning everybody is allowed to take it. So in Episcopal services everyone takes communion, except me. And that's kindof weird.
First Unitarian Church of San Jose is much less specific with its God concepts. They use amorphous, pantheistic words like "Spirit". Now, pantheism really doesn't get around the problem, because if God is the natural order then God is evil. And if God is that spontaneous force inside each of us that moves us towards collective action, then the Rodney King riots were godly acts.
I can put up with pantheism, though. I can also put up with all the women preachers who talk like they're everybody's mother. And I can put up with all the male preachers who talk like they're everybody's mother. What I can't put up with is all the unfamiliarity that comes with a UU service. Last summer I stopped going to the UU church in San Diego because they all did the Hokey Pokey before sending the kids off to Sunday school. I haven't seen them do the Hokey Pokey in the San Jose church, but I have seen a screening of a video on all the different "paths" in Latin America. It mentioned the evil Spaniards who "robbed" the Indians of their culture and imposed Roman Catholocism, and it also mentioned that charming little tribe that wanders the mountains of Central America completely naked, with only the simplest tools, and worshiping only the nature around them. It also mentioned the phrase "Two is less than One", which I'm still trying to mull over in my head. After mentioning Santeria and other syncretist paths, the narrator suggested that the Unitarian Universalist Church can offer a syncretist path that weaves together the religious symbols and meanings of all these paths and thereby helps each Latino and Latina to find spiritual meaning in a search of different and related paths.
If that is what I'm going to see after two services in a UU church, what else am I going to see? The video was bad sociology. It does what sociologists call an "eroticization of the other". "Oh look at the cute little Indians wandering naked in the mountains, they must be so much more content than we are!" This video was a symptom of a disorder that I have yet to find a name for. These people like blowing their minds with ideas that are flat-out incomprehensible. You don't have to smoke weed and watch Zeitgeist - just go to the local UU church!
A via media between St. Mark's and First Unitarian can be found at First Congregational Church of San Jose. They have an openness about their God concepts that somehow still fits into a Christian framework. Their Communion prayers were about as theologically non-descript as is humanly possible. That's really nice, cause I would be able to fully participate without worrying about worshipping the wrong kind of God. They have that wonderfully traditional set-up: altar front and center, with a lectern on the right and a raised pulpit on the left, and a HUGE cross hanging from the ceiling. There are plenty of hymns in the service, all accompanied by an organ. Today there was a lot of special music by the handbell choir, and it was very pretty. After the service there was an adult class on border issues. They have another one next week, but I won't be able to attend that class cause I'll be with my family at a memorial lunch for my Aunt Pat. But I do plan on attending that church a little more. I also hear that on Mardi Gras they put on a Talent/No Talent Show. Yeah I know, that's the totally wrong reason to decide on a church. But it shows I might be able to actively participate in this church.
The minister who did the adult education class suggested I look into an American Baptist church, since I was raised a Baptist. Sounds like a good idea, but I might think of that church in the same way I think of the Episcopalian church. At any rate, it's worth looking into.
In short, I haven't finished church shopping. I might have to add more "candidates" to my list. But for now I'll keep going to First Congregational, just to see what I could see.
----------------------------------
Update: The United Church of Christ, which First Congregational is a member of, officially supports H.R. 676 and/or any other health care reform intended to meet certain goals. Of course, the only option that meets the goals of universal access, affordability, comprehensive benefits, choice in physicians and other health care providers, and the elimination of racial and ethnic disparities in coverage is a fully private system, but I don't blame the UCC for not knowing that. You'll notice a completely misinformed, misleading, and delusional cartoon at the bottom of the page.
Seems I have to accept that there isn't such a thing as a liberal church that isn't socialist. I might have to change my criteria: instead of making an official socialist stance a grounds for disconsidering, I'll have to look at whether (a) socialist positions are preached from the pulpit, and (b) whether I look like I share that position by attending as a visitor and listening. First Congregational can be forgiven, I guess, since health "reform" was supported at the denominational level, and not advocated by a vote of unison by the congregation. I wouldn't be advocating health "reform" by visiting and listening to their hymns and sermons. The Quaker church, on the other hand, relies on what they call consensus, which means they don't approve of anything unless there isn't a single objection raised. Since I didn't raise any objection to their health minute - even though I'm not a member of the church - I supposedly supported health care "reform".
I did a search at American Baptist Churches' website and found that I already have visited the local ABC church. In fact, one of their members (and maybe their church pianist) was my piano teacher for a time. I also once visited that church with my brother and parents, back when we were church shopping as a family. That was the first time I heard a sermon given by a woman. She was sporting a sharp suit dress and heels. And she was using Power Point. The music was done by a worship band, which basically is what you would hear if you tune in to FM 91.9 K-LOVE. And the church is way too theologically conventional. Overall, the praxy isn't anywhere near ortho enough, but the doxy is WAY too ortho.
I've already posted a video on what things I'm looking for in churches, but that wasn't really a report. I didn't say whether these churches actually have those things I'm looking for. That's what I'm going to do here.
The first church I visited was the Friends' Meeting in San Jose. I feel sorry that the one thing I've ever written about them was a little negative. So before I say what I'm going to, I must point out that the Quaker Church in San Jose is a charming little place that everyone should visit at least once. I should also say that the Quakers are generous enough to allow Santa Clara County Activists for Animals to use their building for free. I can't be grateful enough for that. They also have a potluck almost every Sunday.
Now, to say what I think of them as a church. I mentioned in my video that the first church to officially endorse universal healthcare is the first one I'll stop going to. The Quaker Church did just that when they passed a minute in their "Business Worship" calling for mandatory, federally-funded health coverage and expressing preference for a single-payer system.
Someone had contended in the previous business meeting that forcing people to get health coverage can be a violation of their conscience, so they postponed the decision for a month (business meetings are once a month). That person wasn't at this meeting, everyone knew she wouldn't be at the meeting, and they passed the minute without her. I could have raised my voice in opposition, but there were a few reasons I didn't. For one thing, I am not a "convinced" Quaker. Even though I am welcome to participate in the business meeting, and even though they wouldn't pass a measure if I oppose it, I feel very uncomfortable keeping them from saying something that 99% of them agree with. I also felt uncomfortable saying anything against it because just the previous business meeting I sternly told all of them that I oppose the use of lethal force against any sentient being on my behalf, and that they're going to have to figure out a way to deal with their gopher problem without killing any gophers. I hate to sound like the contrarian.
Another thing I should say about Quaker business meetings: the size of the church more than doubles - maybe quadruples - on business meeting days. Lots and lots of people show up only on the Sunday that they have the business meetings. There are other people who show up a little more often, but maybe every other Sunday. I didn't say this in my video, but that's not the type of attendance I want to see in a church. I really can't "do church" with people who I can't count on being there every week.
There is one other reason I will likely decide against making the Friends' Meeting my "home church". I don't have a Quaker temperament. I can't deal with keeping my eyes closed and sitting still in complete silence for a whole hour. I wasn't raised a Quaker. I was raised a Baptist. I need someone standing above me looking down at me telling me what I should and shouldn't do. And I need lots and lots of music.
Lots and lots of music (and someone telling me what to do) can be heard at St. Mark's Episcopal Church in Santa Clara. If you like hymns and organs, St. Mark's is a place you should visit. Also, there's an impressive diversity in the congregation - you can find just about any kind of person there, so long as they're white (or a black autistic kid adopted by a lesbian couple). But seriously, there are both conservatives and liberals in the church, and that would make a quasi-conservative like me quite happy.
As is common in Episcopal churches, the preacher is a white woman who talks as if she's everybody's mother. And her sermon dripped with the 3-letter G-word. If you could wring it out, it would still drip with that word.
Like the services of other noticeably Catholic denominations, the Episcopal service revolves around the Eucharist. And as in other noticeably Catholic denominations, the Eucharist is performed after everyone recites the Apostles' Creed or the Nicene Creed. Both these creeds declare belief in "God, the Father Almighty" who made the earth and everything on it. I already wrote a Facebook note entitled "Went to Church Today" where I explain my discomfort with this, but I'll write it here. If I take Communion after professing belief in the "Maker of all things visible and invisible", wouldn't I then be endorsing the food chain, and thus the subjugation of innumerable sentient beings? If God is not the creator of evil, then he cannot be the creator of the natural order.
The Episcopal church has Open Communion, meaning everybody is allowed to take it. So in Episcopal services everyone takes communion, except me. And that's kindof weird.
First Unitarian Church of San Jose is much less specific with its God concepts. They use amorphous, pantheistic words like "Spirit". Now, pantheism really doesn't get around the problem, because if God is the natural order then God is evil. And if God is that spontaneous force inside each of us that moves us towards collective action, then the Rodney King riots were godly acts.
I can put up with pantheism, though. I can also put up with all the women preachers who talk like they're everybody's mother. And I can put up with all the male preachers who talk like they're everybody's mother. What I can't put up with is all the unfamiliarity that comes with a UU service. Last summer I stopped going to the UU church in San Diego because they all did the Hokey Pokey before sending the kids off to Sunday school. I haven't seen them do the Hokey Pokey in the San Jose church, but I have seen a screening of a video on all the different "paths" in Latin America. It mentioned the evil Spaniards who "robbed" the Indians of their culture and imposed Roman Catholocism, and it also mentioned that charming little tribe that wanders the mountains of Central America completely naked, with only the simplest tools, and worshiping only the nature around them. It also mentioned the phrase "Two is less than One", which I'm still trying to mull over in my head. After mentioning Santeria and other syncretist paths, the narrator suggested that the Unitarian Universalist Church can offer a syncretist path that weaves together the religious symbols and meanings of all these paths and thereby helps each Latino and Latina to find spiritual meaning in a search of different and related paths.
If that is what I'm going to see after two services in a UU church, what else am I going to see? The video was bad sociology. It does what sociologists call an "eroticization of the other". "Oh look at the cute little Indians wandering naked in the mountains, they must be so much more content than we are!" This video was a symptom of a disorder that I have yet to find a name for. These people like blowing their minds with ideas that are flat-out incomprehensible. You don't have to smoke weed and watch Zeitgeist - just go to the local UU church!
A via media between St. Mark's and First Unitarian can be found at First Congregational Church of San Jose. They have an openness about their God concepts that somehow still fits into a Christian framework. Their Communion prayers were about as theologically non-descript as is humanly possible. That's really nice, cause I would be able to fully participate without worrying about worshipping the wrong kind of God. They have that wonderfully traditional set-up: altar front and center, with a lectern on the right and a raised pulpit on the left, and a HUGE cross hanging from the ceiling. There are plenty of hymns in the service, all accompanied by an organ. Today there was a lot of special music by the handbell choir, and it was very pretty. After the service there was an adult class on border issues. They have another one next week, but I won't be able to attend that class cause I'll be with my family at a memorial lunch for my Aunt Pat. But I do plan on attending that church a little more. I also hear that on Mardi Gras they put on a Talent/No Talent Show. Yeah I know, that's the totally wrong reason to decide on a church. But it shows I might be able to actively participate in this church.
The minister who did the adult education class suggested I look into an American Baptist church, since I was raised a Baptist. Sounds like a good idea, but I might think of that church in the same way I think of the Episcopalian church. At any rate, it's worth looking into.
In short, I haven't finished church shopping. I might have to add more "candidates" to my list. But for now I'll keep going to First Congregational, just to see what I could see.
----------------------------------
Update: The United Church of Christ, which First Congregational is a member of, officially supports H.R. 676 and/or any other health care reform intended to meet certain goals. Of course, the only option that meets the goals of universal access, affordability, comprehensive benefits, choice in physicians and other health care providers, and the elimination of racial and ethnic disparities in coverage is a fully private system, but I don't blame the UCC for not knowing that. You'll notice a completely misinformed, misleading, and delusional cartoon at the bottom of the page.
Seems I have to accept that there isn't such a thing as a liberal church that isn't socialist. I might have to change my criteria: instead of making an official socialist stance a grounds for disconsidering, I'll have to look at whether (a) socialist positions are preached from the pulpit, and (b) whether I look like I share that position by attending as a visitor and listening. First Congregational can be forgiven, I guess, since health "reform" was supported at the denominational level, and not advocated by a vote of unison by the congregation. I wouldn't be advocating health "reform" by visiting and listening to their hymns and sermons. The Quaker church, on the other hand, relies on what they call consensus, which means they don't approve of anything unless there isn't a single objection raised. Since I didn't raise any objection to their health minute - even though I'm not a member of the church - I supposedly supported health care "reform".
I did a search at American Baptist Churches' website and found that I already have visited the local ABC church. In fact, one of their members (and maybe their church pianist) was my piano teacher for a time. I also once visited that church with my brother and parents, back when we were church shopping as a family. That was the first time I heard a sermon given by a woman. She was sporting a sharp suit dress and heels. And she was using Power Point. The music was done by a worship band, which basically is what you would hear if you tune in to FM 91.9 K-LOVE. And the church is way too theologically conventional. Overall, the praxy isn't anywhere near ortho enough, but the doxy is WAY too ortho.
Saturday, August 15, 2009
Bisectuality
An article that the Sword of the Lord borrowed from the Institute on Religion and Democracy caught my eye: "The apparent rejection of a controversial candidate for bishop in the Episcopal Church could be a historic move...Kevin Thew Forrester has not received the necessary consent of the majority of the diocesan standing committees...
"...Forrester first drew attention for his Zen Buddhist 'lay' ordination, earning him the moniker of the 'Buddhist Bishop.' Further investigation of his practices revealed unilateral editing of the Book of Common Prayer's baptismal rite and the inserting of a verse from the Koran into a church service as the Word of God."
What's the Qur'an verse that Forrester stuck in? According to these folks, the verse was: "Those who fulfill Allah's pact, and break not the covenant, and those who join what Allah has commanded to be joined, and fear their Lord, and dread the evil reckoning". Since "Allah" is just the literal Arabic word (al ilah) for "The God", you could stick "God" or "The Lord" wherever the passage says "Allah" and you'll get something that sounds like it came straight out of the Bible.
We can infer that Forrerster has a non-fundamentalist view of the "Word of God". He finds religious inspiration in all sorts of places, and judges a passage not by what book it came from but by what it says. Forrester is one of those people who treats non-Christian religious texts the same way they treat the Bible - pick this passage and that passage, interpret this one way and that another, and pretend the rest isn't there until someone presses you to acknowledge that it actually is, and then brush it off as being for another people in another time. Of course, fundamentalists treat the Bible the same exact way, but I've already written about that.
These Episcopalians concede that Buddhist meditation doesn't necessarily conflict with Christianity, but they question whether a bi-sect-ual Bishop can "guard the faith, unity, and discipline of the Church". I don't know the answer to that question, and I'm not the one to give it. That answer should be given by the diocesan standing committees, and apparently they gave it.
"...The last candidate rejected on purely theological grounds was James de Koven, denied consent as bishop of Illinois in 1875."
Like Forrester, James deKoven was elected bishop, but not given consent by the committees. He was a leader of the "Anglo-Catholic" movement, and his ritualist stance was too controversial. He had it easy, though - being denied an episcopate wasn't the worst penalty some men received for not being Protestant enough.
"Smells and Bells" were pretty much banned in the Anglican Episcopal Church by Parliament's passage of the Public Worship Regulation Act 1874. Five priests did time in prison after being prosecuted under this law. They weren't imprisoned for breaking this law, though. They were imprisoned for "contempt of court". Since they rejected the authority of the new law, they rejected the authority of the new court it formed, and so they didn't show up to their court dates.
"...Forrester first drew attention for his Zen Buddhist 'lay' ordination, earning him the moniker of the 'Buddhist Bishop.' Further investigation of his practices revealed unilateral editing of the Book of Common Prayer's baptismal rite and the inserting of a verse from the Koran into a church service as the Word of God."
What's the Qur'an verse that Forrester stuck in? According to these folks, the verse was: "Those who fulfill Allah's pact, and break not the covenant, and those who join what Allah has commanded to be joined, and fear their Lord, and dread the evil reckoning". Since "Allah" is just the literal Arabic word (al ilah) for "The God", you could stick "God" or "The Lord" wherever the passage says "Allah" and you'll get something that sounds like it came straight out of the Bible.
We can infer that Forrerster has a non-fundamentalist view of the "Word of God". He finds religious inspiration in all sorts of places, and judges a passage not by what book it came from but by what it says. Forrester is one of those people who treats non-Christian religious texts the same way they treat the Bible - pick this passage and that passage, interpret this one way and that another, and pretend the rest isn't there until someone presses you to acknowledge that it actually is, and then brush it off as being for another people in another time. Of course, fundamentalists treat the Bible the same exact way, but I've already written about that.
These Episcopalians concede that Buddhist meditation doesn't necessarily conflict with Christianity, but they question whether a bi-sect-ual Bishop can "guard the faith, unity, and discipline of the Church". I don't know the answer to that question, and I'm not the one to give it. That answer should be given by the diocesan standing committees, and apparently they gave it.
"...The last candidate rejected on purely theological grounds was James de Koven, denied consent as bishop of Illinois in 1875."
Like Forrester, James deKoven was elected bishop, but not given consent by the committees. He was a leader of the "Anglo-Catholic" movement, and his ritualist stance was too controversial. He had it easy, though - being denied an episcopate wasn't the worst penalty some men received for not being Protestant enough.
"Smells and Bells" were pretty much banned in the Anglican Episcopal Church by Parliament's passage of the Public Worship Regulation Act 1874. Five priests did time in prison after being prosecuted under this law. They weren't imprisoned for breaking this law, though. They were imprisoned for "contempt of court". Since they rejected the authority of the new law, they rejected the authority of the new court it formed, and so they didn't show up to their court dates.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Followers
About Me
- Isaiah
- I am a part-time philosopher and a former immigration paralegal with a BA in philosophy and a paralegal certificate from UC San Diego.