No matter how much I love the look and "feel" of pulpits, I can't help but acknowledge that I only like the pulpits that are filled by me - which right now is none. And if I only like them if they're filled by me, then there really isn't any good reason for me to like them.
Pulpits are symbols of authority. They are armored. They are bulwarks, or towers. They are impregnable. They are raised above the common folk. The words from the pulpit come down to the people from above, as if from God.
The preacher's location during the sermon can say a good bit about what kind of relations are idealized. If the preacher is set apart, or above, then along with the content of his sermon he's communicating the idea that his sermon must be true (or is more likely to be true) by virtue of his office.
If his location is to present his words as they are, which is as the words of just another man, then it has to be on the same level as and not too far away from the congregation, and it can't be marked by a wall or reading desk that looks like a battlement or any other thing that looks like it's supposed to protect him from riff raff.
It shouldn't even be a chair on a platform, because that looks like a throne in a court.
The best location for a preacher is at the end of a table. Yes, a table. I think pews or rows of seats in an auditorium or "sanctuary" should be replaced by a dining table. Religious observances should celebrate those things that give life value. And so, the ritual that is most pleasurable and most accessible, and thus most able to bind a number of people in an enriching relationship and to express the goodness of that interaction, and which is thereby the most sacred kind of ritual possible, is a meal. In the Esaian church this meal is to be vegan (veganic if possible). If it is the tradition to have meals while sitting on the floor, as is common in the eating halls of gurdwaras even today, then the preacher is to sit on the floor with everybody else.
Of course, the preacher's role is minimal. Outside the communion hall he should start by giving thanks to no one in particular for the sunshine, and for the rain, and should make a wish for rain, as appropriate. Once inside the dining hall he sits down with the others and after a beat (that is, a very short pause) he gives his sermon, which should be like an oral blog entry on what's on his mind. After a few volunteers help him set the table and serve the food, he blesses the meal, or asks someone to bless it. The blessing should be short and sweet, like "We give thanks for the food before us, and for the hands that made it. May our next few moments together be a warm time of fellowship. Amen." And that's it. Preacher's role fini. After that they get down to the real business of the service, which is eating and chatting.
Wednesday, February 3, 2010
Tuesday, February 2, 2010
God not Supernatural, says Father
It must have been a year or two ago when my dad and I were talking about the difficulty with using the words "natural" and "supernatural". I myself prefered at the time to use a word I learned in my sociology of religion class - supra-empirical. A supra-empirical postulate is an assumption you can't test. These days I don't use the word supra-empirical to describe "supernatural" stuff because the supra-empirical also includes moral premises, and I don't think belief in gods and ghosts is the same kind of belief as belief in the right to live.
Anyway, back to the discussion. At that time I didn't like "supernatural" because I didn't believe there was such a thing as nature. No ecosystem that includes animals is a pristine, untouched wildland. A lot of the forces that shape "nature" are the actions of beings who are appropriating resources to meet their own needs. A gang of beavers making their dam doesn't seem that categorically different to me from human beings making a house. And so, the "natural" and "artificial" distinction didn't make much sense to me.
This went beyond my doubt about the difference between "Nature's deeds" and "Man's deeds", and brought in doubt about the difference between "Nature's and Man's deeds" and "God's and angels' and demons' deeds". What are supernatural phenomena supposed to be, but the actions of unseen beings who are appropriating resources to meet their needs and desires? And how is that categorically different from animals' appropriation of their natural environment?
The supposed difference is that the actions of some beings are determined by "natural" processes while the actions of other beings aren't. But I don't know any compelling reason to suppose that human actions and states of mind aren't determined by physical processes. And if God and angels and demons are motivated to want things and do things, and to react in the world to things that occur in the world, then I don't see why they aren't affected by "natural" processes, either. And if they are affected by "natural" processes, then that pretty much means that an aspect of their being is determined by "natural" processes. (I must say that I probably didn't go into this much detail about it in my conversation with my dad.)
My dad, too, was uncomfortable with the word "supernatural", especially when used to describe God. If God is eternal, then He had no beginning, and no one could have made Him. And if He is unchanging, then no one could alter Him. In the sense of "pristine untouched wildland", God as traditionally conceived is the very definition of natural.
Now, my dad isn't exactly a Calvinist in theology. He does believe that God can be motivated to act, and that God as a "person" isn't an unmovable rock or a "pristine untouched wildland". My dad thinks of sovereignty as the ability to change, and if God isn't moved by prayer, then God is not soveriegn. (Calvinists believe that prayer's value is not its efficacy in moving God, that prayer probably doesn't change God's mind anyway, and that God's answers to prayer occur because of predestination, or because of foreknowlege, or something like that.)
I'm going to have to end here, because if I don't I'll ramble on forever. I'll just conclude with one thing. The word "natural" has several different meanings, two of which look like complete opposites of each other. On the one hand, "natural" can mean pristine, untouched, not tampered with, unaffected. On the other, "natural" means affected, altered, and determined by surounding factors.
Anyway, back to the discussion. At that time I didn't like "supernatural" because I didn't believe there was such a thing as nature. No ecosystem that includes animals is a pristine, untouched wildland. A lot of the forces that shape "nature" are the actions of beings who are appropriating resources to meet their own needs. A gang of beavers making their dam doesn't seem that categorically different to me from human beings making a house. And so, the "natural" and "artificial" distinction didn't make much sense to me.
This went beyond my doubt about the difference between "Nature's deeds" and "Man's deeds", and brought in doubt about the difference between "Nature's and Man's deeds" and "God's and angels' and demons' deeds". What are supernatural phenomena supposed to be, but the actions of unseen beings who are appropriating resources to meet their needs and desires? And how is that categorically different from animals' appropriation of their natural environment?
The supposed difference is that the actions of some beings are determined by "natural" processes while the actions of other beings aren't. But I don't know any compelling reason to suppose that human actions and states of mind aren't determined by physical processes. And if God and angels and demons are motivated to want things and do things, and to react in the world to things that occur in the world, then I don't see why they aren't affected by "natural" processes, either. And if they are affected by "natural" processes, then that pretty much means that an aspect of their being is determined by "natural" processes. (I must say that I probably didn't go into this much detail about it in my conversation with my dad.)
My dad, too, was uncomfortable with the word "supernatural", especially when used to describe God. If God is eternal, then He had no beginning, and no one could have made Him. And if He is unchanging, then no one could alter Him. In the sense of "pristine untouched wildland", God as traditionally conceived is the very definition of natural.
Now, my dad isn't exactly a Calvinist in theology. He does believe that God can be motivated to act, and that God as a "person" isn't an unmovable rock or a "pristine untouched wildland". My dad thinks of sovereignty as the ability to change, and if God isn't moved by prayer, then God is not soveriegn. (Calvinists believe that prayer's value is not its efficacy in moving God, that prayer probably doesn't change God's mind anyway, and that God's answers to prayer occur because of predestination, or because of foreknowlege, or something like that.)
I'm going to have to end here, because if I don't I'll ramble on forever. I'll just conclude with one thing. The word "natural" has several different meanings, two of which look like complete opposites of each other. On the one hand, "natural" can mean pristine, untouched, not tampered with, unaffected. On the other, "natural" means affected, altered, and determined by surounding factors.
Laurence Vance, Ron Paul, Abortion
In response to recent criticisms of the Doctors Paul, Laurence Vance wrote this article that was published yesterday at LRC. Every pro-life conservative should read it. He says a lot of good things in it. He emphasizes that real change is social change, not political change, and that programs asserted from the top down end up like Prohibition. He mentions that there are all sorts of non-political routes that the pro-life movement could take besides the political route, which has progressed unremarkably at best. And, he suggests between the lines that a program for the rights of the preborn is pretty much meaningless outside of a program for total freedom.
I do have some criticisms of the article, though, and it just wouldn't be right for me to suggest his article without also offering my criticisms of it.
For one thing, Vance keeps talking about the Constitution. The Constitution has no inherent authority. It is just another piece of positive "law", and at best is just a useful legal tool to keep a positive law system relatively "libertarian".
Also, Vance rebukes American Right to Life for attacking national sovereignty. But frankly, there is no such thing as national sovereignty. If the people of another country start genociding Christians or Jews, we would have a right to violently intervene. That's half of what we mean when we say "right to live". To say that individuals don't have the right to intervene to stop a genocide abroad is to say that the rights of individuals depend on the dictates of the government they live under - and that smacks of anti-individual and pro-government sentiment. Our opposition to U.S. intervention abroad should be based not on some myth called "national sovereignty", but on the principle of individual sovereignty - that is, on the moral opposition to killing noncombatants and to forcing taxpayers to fund something they don't want to fund. If the proposal was for the U.S. military to intervene, sure I would oppose that. But if private individuals and groups wanted to intervene, and were subject to a procedure by which they are held accountable for any nondiscriminate or disproportionate violence, I'd have to say let them.
I do have some criticisms of the article, though, and it just wouldn't be right for me to suggest his article without also offering my criticisms of it.
For one thing, Vance keeps talking about the Constitution. The Constitution has no inherent authority. It is just another piece of positive "law", and at best is just a useful legal tool to keep a positive law system relatively "libertarian".
Also, Vance rebukes American Right to Life for attacking national sovereignty. But frankly, there is no such thing as national sovereignty. If the people of another country start genociding Christians or Jews, we would have a right to violently intervene. That's half of what we mean when we say "right to live". To say that individuals don't have the right to intervene to stop a genocide abroad is to say that the rights of individuals depend on the dictates of the government they live under - and that smacks of anti-individual and pro-government sentiment. Our opposition to U.S. intervention abroad should be based not on some myth called "national sovereignty", but on the principle of individual sovereignty - that is, on the moral opposition to killing noncombatants and to forcing taxpayers to fund something they don't want to fund. If the proposal was for the U.S. military to intervene, sure I would oppose that. But if private individuals and groups wanted to intervene, and were subject to a procedure by which they are held accountable for any nondiscriminate or disproportionate violence, I'd have to say let them.
Wednesday, January 27, 2010
Indigenous Rights
I was just reading about Avatar (sorry, I haven't watched it yet) and I was reminded of The Man's propensity to wipe out or enslave any new people he comes in contact with. Supposing that the next decade or two will see the rise of White Flight to some Third World country, and supposing that the white settlers will try to set up some libertarian regime in the New New World, I would like to make clear some things about indigenous modes of subsitence which not everyone will find as legitimate under an individual rights framework but which I consider to be fully legitimate under individual rights.
Water sources and waterways that are used collectively are more than likely owned collectively. This doesn't make me a socialist or a tree hugger. Individuals have the right to homestead, and they have the right to homestead in groups. If a water source is used in a way that excludes other uses of it (for example, drinking excludes pollution), then it is appropriated for a particular use. And in the case that this use is made by many people in general (which is most of the time), the water source is owned by the "unorganized public". No local official has the authority to just declare whole waterways the property of some corporation. You would need the consent of the owners for that to be legitimate, and in the case of rivers, the "owners" are every single person who regularly drinks from, boats in, swims in, plays in, and fishes in that river. I'm not saying privatization is always and in all places illegitimate. I'm just saying that transfer of title is illegitimate without the consent of the owner, and in the case of rivers that's pretty hard to get.
Indigenous people and concerned settlers have the right to coerce people to stop polluting. Most environmental "reform" I see provides ways for companies to basically buy licenses to pollute. And unfortunately, I've heard a few self-styled libertarians show support for arrangements like these when they speak in favor of people being free to do whatever they want to anybody and anything else, so long as they compensate for damages. If you have a right to remain whole in your person and things, then you have a right not just to demand compensation for aggression against you, but you also have a right to use a certain amount of force to stop the aggression. We have no reason to suppose that the deformed baby sold his right to bodily integrity by being conceived to a woman who was a member of a group whose officials received money in "compensation" for dumping. If you want to buy "dumping rights", you have to follow a procedure similar to the one mentioned above. And if you didn't get dumping rights under that kind of procedure, then you don't have a right to pollute (which is basically dumping on other people's property, and in some cases amounts to poisoning people), and anyone who wants to has the right to force you to stop.
Land that is frequently and regularly used collectively is more than likely owned collectively. Again, this doesn't make me a socialist or a tree hugger. It's just that the labor of the "unorganized public" appropriates land just as legitimately as individual labor, and that the right of access connected to first use is held by each individual first user and bequeathed to each subsequent user. This means, basically, that each indigenous person is a co-owner of regularly-used open land. (Which, quite frankly, looks to me like the more "natural" method of land appropriation and ownership - personal homes and gardens aside, since humans first settle land "together" and first use resources together.) Since every user of the land is "naturally" an owner of it, frequently-used open land cannot legitimately be sold by anyone who is not expressly given that permission by every single person who has gathered food in that land. If that permission is not given by every single owner, then the purchase is void. If you did not buy land according to the method prescribed here, then any use of "your" land that deprives individuals of resources they traditionally had access to is an act of theft, and the deprived indigenous people have a right not just to demand compensation from you, but also to force you to stop using "your" land that way.
Just wanted to set some things straight here. Didn't want to see libertarian property theory used to justify the next ethnocide, genocide, or mass subjugation...
Water sources and waterways that are used collectively are more than likely owned collectively. This doesn't make me a socialist or a tree hugger. Individuals have the right to homestead, and they have the right to homestead in groups. If a water source is used in a way that excludes other uses of it (for example, drinking excludes pollution), then it is appropriated for a particular use. And in the case that this use is made by many people in general (which is most of the time), the water source is owned by the "unorganized public". No local official has the authority to just declare whole waterways the property of some corporation. You would need the consent of the owners for that to be legitimate, and in the case of rivers, the "owners" are every single person who regularly drinks from, boats in, swims in, plays in, and fishes in that river. I'm not saying privatization is always and in all places illegitimate. I'm just saying that transfer of title is illegitimate without the consent of the owner, and in the case of rivers that's pretty hard to get.
Indigenous people and concerned settlers have the right to coerce people to stop polluting. Most environmental "reform" I see provides ways for companies to basically buy licenses to pollute. And unfortunately, I've heard a few self-styled libertarians show support for arrangements like these when they speak in favor of people being free to do whatever they want to anybody and anything else, so long as they compensate for damages. If you have a right to remain whole in your person and things, then you have a right not just to demand compensation for aggression against you, but you also have a right to use a certain amount of force to stop the aggression. We have no reason to suppose that the deformed baby sold his right to bodily integrity by being conceived to a woman who was a member of a group whose officials received money in "compensation" for dumping. If you want to buy "dumping rights", you have to follow a procedure similar to the one mentioned above. And if you didn't get dumping rights under that kind of procedure, then you don't have a right to pollute (which is basically dumping on other people's property, and in some cases amounts to poisoning people), and anyone who wants to has the right to force you to stop.
Land that is frequently and regularly used collectively is more than likely owned collectively. Again, this doesn't make me a socialist or a tree hugger. It's just that the labor of the "unorganized public" appropriates land just as legitimately as individual labor, and that the right of access connected to first use is held by each individual first user and bequeathed to each subsequent user. This means, basically, that each indigenous person is a co-owner of regularly-used open land. (Which, quite frankly, looks to me like the more "natural" method of land appropriation and ownership - personal homes and gardens aside, since humans first settle land "together" and first use resources together.) Since every user of the land is "naturally" an owner of it, frequently-used open land cannot legitimately be sold by anyone who is not expressly given that permission by every single person who has gathered food in that land. If that permission is not given by every single owner, then the purchase is void. If you did not buy land according to the method prescribed here, then any use of "your" land that deprives individuals of resources they traditionally had access to is an act of theft, and the deprived indigenous people have a right not just to demand compensation from you, but also to force you to stop using "your" land that way.
Just wanted to set some things straight here. Didn't want to see libertarian property theory used to justify the next ethnocide, genocide, or mass subjugation...
Monday, January 25, 2010
"Well you choose to live here, so..."
You've heard the argument before, and you yourself have probably made it before. In short, it says that since you "choose" to live here, you agree to the government and laws here, and all of the obligations the government prescribes apply to you because you agreed to them by contract.
Now, we all know that those who make this argument don't pretend that the U.S.-born among us made that "choice" when we were born. Nobody chooses where they get born. And all of us know that the "choice" wasn't about where we'll grow up. We all know that nobody chooses where they get raised. So already we can see that it makes a pretty weak case for government's authority over young children.
The argument only makes one bit of sense when it refers to an in-action. By not leaving, we choose to stay - so the argument goes. Of course, this assumes that finding a new country to live in is as easy as finding a new apartment to move into. If you want to make that case, go ahead and try.
The difficulty of trying to shop for governments aside, there is one major downside to trying to make this kind of argument. Once you make this argument, you remove the grounds for any authority-based criticism you have of government. You can't argue about Constitutional limits to government because - well - you choose to live in this country! Don't like the way this government does things? Find another country! The government can take your property whenever it wants, because you voluntarily assent to that authority by staying on land within its borders. Don't like it? Well you chose it! You can't argue about wars, abortions, or taxes. By not leaving, you agree to the actions that this government takes, and if this government finds you guilty of terrorism and decides to kill you, well then you have the procedural duty to die because that's the obligation you take on by not leaving.
If government authority is to make any sense (and I don't think it makes any), then it has to be based on something other than your "voluntary" agreement to live under it. No one gets complete and arbitrary authority over you when you just happen to be on their territory. When I was a Junior in college I believed government gets its authority not from consent of the governed, but by its protection of and respect for its subjects' rights. I was of course presuming that government can possibly respect people's rights by forcing them to patronize it...
Now, we all know that those who make this argument don't pretend that the U.S.-born among us made that "choice" when we were born. Nobody chooses where they get born. And all of us know that the "choice" wasn't about where we'll grow up. We all know that nobody chooses where they get raised. So already we can see that it makes a pretty weak case for government's authority over young children.
The argument only makes one bit of sense when it refers to an in-action. By not leaving, we choose to stay - so the argument goes. Of course, this assumes that finding a new country to live in is as easy as finding a new apartment to move into. If you want to make that case, go ahead and try.
The difficulty of trying to shop for governments aside, there is one major downside to trying to make this kind of argument. Once you make this argument, you remove the grounds for any authority-based criticism you have of government. You can't argue about Constitutional limits to government because - well - you choose to live in this country! Don't like the way this government does things? Find another country! The government can take your property whenever it wants, because you voluntarily assent to that authority by staying on land within its borders. Don't like it? Well you chose it! You can't argue about wars, abortions, or taxes. By not leaving, you agree to the actions that this government takes, and if this government finds you guilty of terrorism and decides to kill you, well then you have the procedural duty to die because that's the obligation you take on by not leaving.
If government authority is to make any sense (and I don't think it makes any), then it has to be based on something other than your "voluntary" agreement to live under it. No one gets complete and arbitrary authority over you when you just happen to be on their territory. When I was a Junior in college I believed government gets its authority not from consent of the governed, but by its protection of and respect for its subjects' rights. I was of course presuming that government can possibly respect people's rights by forcing them to patronize it...
Saturday, January 16, 2010
Addendum to "The Conservative Case for Gay Marriage"
Ted Olson's recent article, though well written, lacks the "get off my lawn" sentiment that the conservative movement is once again starting to show. Some of his arguments simply shouldn't resonate with Small Government Conservatives. He refers to Lincoln at least twice, as if Lincoln had anything to do with a small government, and he writes at length about "the value of strong families, lasting domestic relationships, and communities populated by persons with recognized and sanctioned bonds to one another", as if it's any of Government's business to engineer society. And, he misses some major arguments that SHOULD resonate with Small Government Conservatives.
The first argument that he should have brought in is freedom of religion. Conservatives view Separation of Church and State as a wall meant to protect the religious sphere from Government intrusion. Matters of God should not be matters of Government, and any act of Government to regulate, oversee, or restrict religious activity is an unjust denial of the individual's right to follow his or her own conscience. And, needless to say, Conservatives view marriage as a God-ordained institution. If marriage is a sacred journey, then it too should be protected against the intrusions of Government. Just as a preacher should be free to preach without having to get the Government's permission, so too should a couple be free to marry without having to get the Government's permission. This means, of course, that Government should get completely out of the marriage business, just as it should get out of a whole lot of other businesses. There should be no such thing as a marriage license.
Now, this particular argument doesn't work on all Conservatives, since not all Conservatives view marriage as a matter of God. But there is another argument that is just as "get off my lawn" as the former, and which can resonate with secularists. This argument is the personal and family freedom argument. The religious sphere isn't the only sphere that should be protected from Government. Every aspect of personal life should be safe from Government's eyes and fingers. Conservatives frequently talk about a man's rights to live his own way, to build his cabin where he wants to, to send his kids to whichever school he thinks best, or to teach them at home, to decide on his own or with his wife what they and their kids will eat and wear and how they will travel and how they will pass their time together, etc. We should be free to live our lives without having to grovel for Our Illustrious Overlords' sufferance. As in the former argument, this argument concludes by demanding that Government get out of the way - completely.
The patriot should demand not marriage equality (equality is just another word for a guillotine) but marriage freedom. Of course, I say should, because I have no idea if and only a little confidence that the "Tea Party" movement actually will adopt the "get out of my bedroom" plank. Some Tea Partygoers might be convinced by the arguments above, some might blink and stutter, and others will be reminded of how much they loved the government when their guys were in charge. Whether they start advocating marriage freedom will be an indication of how much they actually believe in personal freedom and Government restraint.
Stay "tuned" for more on Marriage Freedom...
The first argument that he should have brought in is freedom of religion. Conservatives view Separation of Church and State as a wall meant to protect the religious sphere from Government intrusion. Matters of God should not be matters of Government, and any act of Government to regulate, oversee, or restrict religious activity is an unjust denial of the individual's right to follow his or her own conscience. And, needless to say, Conservatives view marriage as a God-ordained institution. If marriage is a sacred journey, then it too should be protected against the intrusions of Government. Just as a preacher should be free to preach without having to get the Government's permission, so too should a couple be free to marry without having to get the Government's permission. This means, of course, that Government should get completely out of the marriage business, just as it should get out of a whole lot of other businesses. There should be no such thing as a marriage license.
Now, this particular argument doesn't work on all Conservatives, since not all Conservatives view marriage as a matter of God. But there is another argument that is just as "get off my lawn" as the former, and which can resonate with secularists. This argument is the personal and family freedom argument. The religious sphere isn't the only sphere that should be protected from Government. Every aspect of personal life should be safe from Government's eyes and fingers. Conservatives frequently talk about a man's rights to live his own way, to build his cabin where he wants to, to send his kids to whichever school he thinks best, or to teach them at home, to decide on his own or with his wife what they and their kids will eat and wear and how they will travel and how they will pass their time together, etc. We should be free to live our lives without having to grovel for Our Illustrious Overlords' sufferance. As in the former argument, this argument concludes by demanding that Government get out of the way - completely.
The patriot should demand not marriage equality (equality is just another word for a guillotine) but marriage freedom. Of course, I say should, because I have no idea if and only a little confidence that the "Tea Party" movement actually will adopt the "get out of my bedroom" plank. Some Tea Partygoers might be convinced by the arguments above, some might blink and stutter, and others will be reminded of how much they loved the government when their guys were in charge. Whether they start advocating marriage freedom will be an indication of how much they actually believe in personal freedom and Government restraint.
Stay "tuned" for more on Marriage Freedom...
Friday, January 15, 2010
When Corporal Punishment is Justified
This is something I've been thinking about since I wrote the second entry of my Sex and Right series. I often think of slavery and beating as horribly evil, and I sometimes describe them as being inherrently evil. But I do think slavery is morally justified in some situations (sans the slavery "contract"). And I think that beating can be justified when the victim and perpetrator agree that that's the best punishment.
First, the pragmatic reasons. Some people would really like to get on with their life without being locked in a labor camp, or having a criminal debt looming over their head. Having an alternative to monetary compensation available to the perpetrator would be nice. Also, the cost of keeping prisoners is quite high. I imagine that mere market forces would keep the number and size of prisons quite small. And, people who absolutely do not want to be in prison would not be productive workers, and would live as leaches on the justice system (which is pretty much how prisoners live today).
Now, the rights-based reasons. The whole purpose of justice is to restore complete sovereignty to the victim by "making right" the crime against her. Any act of justice that is carried out has to take into account her will - it is she who has been victimized, and it is she who has rights over the perpetrator. (This gets complicated when she isn't the only victim.) Yes, there is an upward limit to what she can do to the perpetrator. But I don't think there is any downward limit. If she's a pacifist, she can order him released and cancel his debt, or she can declare his debt cancelled from the moment she's victimized. If she's merciful, she can settle for a debt that is much lower than the cost imposed on her by the crime. Or, she can settle for some kind of non-monetary compensation.
I'm actually unsure whether beating the perpetrator without his consent fits above or below the upward limit of what the crime victim can request. But I am sure that if the perpetrator favors getting beaten over having to pay an overwhelming sum of money, and if the victim is willing to accept his welts and yelps as payment in full, then we have an agreement.
I don't see any reason why this shouldn't also apply to civil cases. If someone is found negligent, and they are unwilling or unable to pay monetary damages, and the plaintiff is willing to settle for welts and yelps, then welts and yelps it shall be.
First, the pragmatic reasons. Some people would really like to get on with their life without being locked in a labor camp, or having a criminal debt looming over their head. Having an alternative to monetary compensation available to the perpetrator would be nice. Also, the cost of keeping prisoners is quite high. I imagine that mere market forces would keep the number and size of prisons quite small. And, people who absolutely do not want to be in prison would not be productive workers, and would live as leaches on the justice system (which is pretty much how prisoners live today).
Now, the rights-based reasons. The whole purpose of justice is to restore complete sovereignty to the victim by "making right" the crime against her. Any act of justice that is carried out has to take into account her will - it is she who has been victimized, and it is she who has rights over the perpetrator. (This gets complicated when she isn't the only victim.) Yes, there is an upward limit to what she can do to the perpetrator. But I don't think there is any downward limit. If she's a pacifist, she can order him released and cancel his debt, or she can declare his debt cancelled from the moment she's victimized. If she's merciful, she can settle for a debt that is much lower than the cost imposed on her by the crime. Or, she can settle for some kind of non-monetary compensation.
I'm actually unsure whether beating the perpetrator without his consent fits above or below the upward limit of what the crime victim can request. But I am sure that if the perpetrator favors getting beaten over having to pay an overwhelming sum of money, and if the victim is willing to accept his welts and yelps as payment in full, then we have an agreement.
I don't see any reason why this shouldn't also apply to civil cases. If someone is found negligent, and they are unwilling or unable to pay monetary damages, and the plaintiff is willing to settle for welts and yelps, then welts and yelps it shall be.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Followers
About Me
- Isaiah
- I am a part-time philosopher and a former immigration paralegal with a BA in philosophy and a paralegal certificate from UC San Diego.