Tuesday, August 11, 2009
Prayer in Public Schools
Thing is, prayer already is allowed in America's public schools. Sure, Engel v. Vitale and Abington School District v. Schempp prohibit public school-sponsored prayer and Bible reading. But that's school-sponsored prayer. Students and teachers are perfectly free to pray at school on their own time. When I was at Wilcox High School in Santa Clara, I regularly organized and attended lunch-time meetings where Christians sang, prayed, discussed their relationships with God, and even heard preaching. It was perfectly legal. And it'll stay legal until China invades to collect its due.
What isn't legal is when someone gets somebody else's religion shoved down their throat. You aren't allowed to teach from the Bible or lead prayer during class time. If a public school teacher were to teach life lessons from the Bible or lead prayer in class, she would be making an "establishment of religion" - basically, forcing someone to practice a religion that he or she doesn't subscribe to. The government's role (if it has one) is to protect your body and your property, not promote your religion.
An early school prayer case was the Edgerton Bible Case. Catholic parents didn't want their kids being led in devotions from a King James Version Bible, because the KJV is a Protestant translation.
What would happen if prayer were "allowed" back in public schools? Might children be taught passages from the Qur'an? Would children be led in Hail Marys? Would lecturers be invited to teach Hinduism from the Bhagvad Gita? Given the religious make-up of the Silicon Valley today, I wouldn't be surprised if that were to happen.
Remember, no one goes to public school becase they want to. They go because they have to. If they don't, their parents get in trouble. Public school students are a captive audience in the most literal sense. So when students are led to do something in class, they're really forced to do it. If you don't want to be forced to pray the Muslim way, then it only makes sense that other people not be forced to pray your way.
As it is, the law on school prayer might be the best way (short of repealing all truancy laws) to respect all public school students' and teachers' liberties. I hate to defend the government, but on this issue you have to be content.
Monday, August 10, 2009
What I think about the Constitution
One thing where I disagree with Ron Paul has more to do with strategy than with policy. Ron Paul obviously would oppose federal subsidies for agriculture. Every animal rights activist agrees that subsidies for the animal industry are to blame for the existence of factory farms and the abuse that occurs there. Ron Paul could have exploited that by calling for an end to agricultural subsidies. He could have advocated other green libertarian policies like the privatization of water and energy, and used those as examples for why the free market is the only sustainable option. I don't know, maybe it wouldn't have worked to attract more leftists to free market ideas. But at any rate, it would have shown some people that free marketeers have an idea of how a free market can address issues that environmentalists and animal rights activists care about.
There's another issue - gold. Ron Paul keeps saying that our Constitution only allows gold and silver to be legal tender. But the problem isn't that we don't have a gold standard; the problem is that we have legal tender. If we want anything vaguely resembling a free market, we have to have a free market in currency - and that means no one should be forced to accept any particular currency as repayment. By forcing people to accept repayment in a particular currency, you lay out the banana peel for inflation. I've heard Ron Paul, Tom Woods, and Peter Schiff say something like that maybe one or two times and no more, and it's a real tragedy, because now people who regard these guys as authorities on free market economics and who don't have the free time to read Austrian banking theory think that to have a free market we need legal tender with a gold standard.
There are several other issues, but I'll concentrate on this one - the Constitution. Ron Paul seems to think that we can keep a free and prosperous country ruled by a strictly-limited government if we read the U.S. Constitution the same way Hasidic Jews read the Tanakh, Mishnah, and Talmud. There are a few problems with Constitutionalism.
As with any text-based religion, you get the problem of interpretation. Just look at Christian fundamentalists. You get people who think you can loose your salvation, people who think once you're saved you're saved even if you go on a rape and murder spree, people who think God decides who gets saved and who doesn't and your prayers have absolutely nothing to do with it, people who think you're not saved unless you start splashing around speaking a language so foreign not even you can understand, people who think we should enforce Mosaic law in the U.S., Westboro Baptist Church, etc. Sure, you can settle a few things by picking a particular text as your ultimate authority. But the Devil's in the details, and how you interpret that text is going to make a whole world of difference. In the past 200 years our nation's legal theorists developed something called "Constitutional Law", which basically is the practice of ambitiously inferring things from the Constitution that aren't mentioned anywhere in the Constitution. The practice would most suredly have developed even if our forefathers stuck to the Articles. Needless to say, the bounds laid out in the Constitution didn't restrain government. This isn't just because there are power-hungry judges and lawyers and bureaucrats out there. It's because the Constitution is incomplete. Frankly, no piece of paper expresses every implication of the principle of liberty. The U.S. Constitution is a good example of this fact. Try this thought experiment: Do you have a Constitutional right to live?
"Well obviously we must," you might think, "because the Constitution is framed according to principles of individual liberty, and individual liberty would be meaningless without the individual's right to live." But if you do that, wouldn't you be introducing as "Constitutional" something that isn't mentioned anywhere in the Constitution? And wouldn't you be as guilty of misconstruing the Constitution and increasing government's role as the black-robed unelected magistrates who write up pages upon pages of opinions that cite pages upon pages of other opinions, and memos, and briefs?
This brings us to another problem with text-based religions like Constitutionalism - from where does the piece of paper get its authority? "From its adherence to principles of individual liberty," you might insist. Well then, fine and good. I believe in individual liberty. But then, the Constitution would have authority only so far as it falls in line with principles of freedom. Parts that don't adhere to these principles, like Article I Section 8 clauses 1, 2, 3, and 5, and the second half of Article I Section 9 clause 2, have no authority, since they contradict individual liberty.
And another thing about authority. If what we're concerned about is the principle of individual liberty, then why even look at the Constitution? Why not just govern ourselves according to principle?
The UK has no written Constitution, and they're doing just as "fine" as we are. Sure, they have all sorts of intrusions like the NHS and gun control, but our individual states have the same thing, and the Constitution says nothing against them doing that. And our federal government has all sorts of intrusive and money-draining things that aren't provided for in the Constitution, which the Court justifies under the "Necessary and Proper" clause.
So no, the Constitution doesn't work and we don't need it. But let's go further: if what we're concerned about is individual liberty, then the Constitution is - how shall I put this - unconsitutional? The form of government that the Constitution provides for is supposedly "self government", a type of government that, to quote Jefferson, derives "its just powers by consent of the governed". How many of the governed? A majority? And does that mean that government should be free to do whatever the majority wants? Well no, we're drawn to an indirect, limited form of government with checks and balances and a Bill of Rights because we know that whatever the majority wants isn't necessarily right. We have to respect the rights of individuals, not the whims of kings and crowds.
Since we want to protect individual rights, we have to regard "the people" and "the governed" not as a faceless unit (which would be collectivism), but as a sea of individuals. If governments derive their just powers by consent of the governed, then no government has authority over a person who doesn't freely give that authority. It doesn't matter that most everybody else wants the form of government laid out in the Constitution. If they want that government, let them have it. But don't force it onto the minority who don't want it. Just because the Constitution was ratified through democratic means doesn't give its government the right to force everyone in this country to submit to it. Democracy is irrelevant. It's two wolves and a sheep deciding what's for dinner.
(And besides, the Constitution was not ratified democratically. Only men were allowed to vote, and land-owning men at that.)
The basic premise of individual liberty is this: that every one is fully sovereign over him or herself, and should be free from invasion of person and property. Since each of us is fully sovereign, none of us should be forced to do things that we don't want to do, or forced to abstain from things that we don't want to abstain from (so long as we're not violating other peoples' rights). That is the rule that governments should follow. If we want to bicker, let's bicker about how to interpret this principle - not how to interpret some piece of paper.
If we want our governments to respect this principle, then we can't have government as we know it. Governments are coercive monopolies - they don't ask the individual for consent. And since they're monopolies, they're bound to grow no matter how limited they are. When there's no competition, there's no incentive to keep costs down, and so the size, inefficiency, and price of government (that is, taxes) increase indefinitely.
Either the form of government laid out in the Constitution can respect individual liberty, or it can't. If it can't, then the U.S. government has no authority and its Constitution is irrelevant. If it can, then we wouldn't recognize it as a government, since it wouldn't assume power over any of us. In other words, if Constitutional government respected our rights, we would all have been able to secede by now, and whether the U.S. Constitution permits a central bank or a public health option would be no concern of ours. This is what I mean when I say "I don't give a shit about the Constitution."
Don't worry about some slippery slope to "progressivism". I'm not loosely interpretting the Constitution to expand government's power. The Constitution already gives government power that it shouldn't have, and if you want to stick to the Constitution, then you want government to keep that unjust power. I'm quite the opposite of a "progressive". I don't want to increase the power of the State. I want to abolish it completely. So please, don't confuse me with Lincoln, T.R., Wilson, F.D.R., L.B.J., Nixon, or any other tyrant that used the founding documents as toilet paper.
As I mentioned at the beginning of this post, none of these differences kept me from voting for Ron Paul in the Republican primary. If he were to run again in 2012, he'd still have my vote. I might even write him in if he doesn't run. Given the typical choices, every vote for a candidate is thrown away no matter what, so I may as well throw my vote away spectacularly.
Wednesday, August 5, 2009
Japanese Fire Balloons
The balloon was one of more than 9,000 fire balloons launched by Japan, and one of the 300 that were found or observed in North America. The six who died that day (seven, really, if you include the pastor's wife's unborn child) were some of the few civilians who died from an Axis attack on North America.
Usually, civilian deaths during war are considered unfortunate side effects of an armed conflict. They're very rarely treated like murders. Intentionally performing actions that are intended to kill civilians and which the agents know may likely kill civilians is called "murder" when the agents are in street clothes and "duty" when the agents wear a uniform.
War is just a really big drive-by shooting. Some people who died deserved it, some people who died didn't, and there's no real way to make sure the only ones who die deserve it. Every government that shells or bombs cities inhabited by civilians intentionally performs acts that obviously will result in civilian deaths, and is nothing better than a criminal gang with big guns and fancy outfits. Killing bystanders in a drive-by shooting is still gang-related murder; killing civilians in war is no different.
The Japanese military was clearly one of the murderers of the seven Oregonians. It launched the balloons, knowing that they may kill civilians, and with the apparent intent to kill civilians. But the Japanese military may not be the only party responsible for the wrongful deaths.
The first launch was in November of 1944. On January 1, 1945, Newsweek ran an article on the "Balloon Mystery". The next day a newspaper ran a similar article. In response, the Office of Censorship instructed newspapers and radio stations to make no mention of balloons and balloon bomb incidents. Reporting on the bombs would "embolden" Japan.
The media complied, and the result was postive, in a way. The Japanese military gave up on the balloon offensive in April. But compliance had its cost. The American public didn't know their country was littered with unexploded ordnance. Had the press reported on the fire balloons, Joan Patzky may have known not to reach for the one she saw, and she and her brother and her friends may have lived fuller lives.
An uninformed public is a vulnerable public. Act to keep them in the dark, and you act against their lives.
The press was guilty of obeying, so maybe they weren't as liable as the government agency that taped their mouths. And since the Office of Censorship didn't intend to kill the Oregonians, it isn't guilty of murdering them. But it is liable for manslaughter. Of course, you don't have to look that hard to find murders that the U.S. Government actually intended.
The U.S. lifted the press blackout after the Oregon deaths. Since the War's end, the remains of 14 fire balloons have been found. The last-known discovery of a functional fire balloon was in 1955 - its payload still lethal after 10 years of rust.
Sunday, August 2, 2009
Sex and Right, Part 2
In the first post of this series I mentioned a 3-shelf hierarchy of prohibitions which (I failed to say) just about everybody uses. At the top, in shelf A, are the things that are so wrong that they should be punishable by law. In the middle, in shelf B, are things that shouldn't be punished by law, but which people have a right to disapprove of. At the bottom, in shelf C, are those things that are so benign that individuals should be free to choose them without fear of either public or private censure. The purpose of this series is to examine the ways people put different sexual acts in different shelves.
Last week I looked at one kind of religious argument, the teleological argument. This week I'll look at something much broader - religious argument in general.
Most of us stick religion in shelf B. Government shouldn't be in the business of telling us which religious beliefs and practices are correct and which ones aren't. Religion is a matter of God, not a matter of government, and so long as we're not hurting others we should be allowed to believe and practice as we see fit.
If government shouldn't be in the business of telling us which religious beliefs are correct and which ones aren't, then it shouldn't be basing its laws on religious belief. To do so would be to pick one religious belief as more valid than another.
Let's take idolatry as an example. If government started enforcing Biblical rules against worshipping idols, we would all think of that as too radical, for a couple reasons. For one thing, every Catholic church and Hindu temple would be burnt to the ground and all their priests would be stoned to death. For another, government would have picked one religious belief (that no physical thing should be an object of religious devotion) over another religious belief (that physical things may be used as objects of religious devotion if they are understood as only symbols of God), and in so doing would have made a "law regarding the establishment of religion".
Now what would happen if U.S. laws about sex were based on religious belief? I really don't know. Clinton and Lewinsky might have been executed for adultery. But if the law against adultery were based on the Bible, Clinton might have been congratulated and offered Lewinsky's hand in marriage. The bottom line is that more than a million different people have more than a million different ideas about what God says about this sexual act and that sexual act. If government were to pick the "sex between a married man and unmarried woman is not adultery since the Bible defines adultery only as sex between a married woman and a man who isn't her husband" view, then it would be establishing that religious view as more valid than the "any sex between a married man or woman and a woman or man not married to him or her is adultery" view.
If government shouldn't be assigning religious belief, then it shouldn't be citing religious belief, either. Blasphemy and idolatry fit into shelf B and not A; so should illicit sex, if the reason to condemn it is God's will. If you want to put a sexual act in shelf A and not B or C, then you have to find a better reason than "it's an abomination before God."
Before you spout off that I want rape legalized, let me assure you that I do believe some sexual acts should be punishable under the law. There are standards we already use to find which religious acts should go into shelf A and which religious acts should go into shelf B. We could use similar standards for sex. Jefferson hints at these standards when he says: "it does me no injury for my neighbor to say there are twenty gods or no God. It neither picks my pocket nor breaks my leg."
Thursday, July 30, 2009
Children and Libertarian Property Theory
Sounds like a good idea, sorta. So long as the kid is completely dependent on the parents, it makes sense that housing, healthcare, and educational decisions be made by the parents on the kid's behalf. It would be better that these decisions be made by someone who likely has an instinct to look out for the child, than that these decisions be made by an agency that is bound to treat the child like another number. But I don't think "property" is the right word to describe the rights that parents have over their children.
Property implies the right to deface or destroy. If children are their parents' property, then the parent has the right not just to curse and beat the child, but also to brand his forehead with a swastika and to harvest organs from him.
My friend did add that the child should be considered not just the parents' property, but the parents' body, and the rights over the child are limited in the same way an adult's rights over his own body are limited. Since we don't have a right to sell ourselves into slavery, we shouldn't have the right to make such drastic and permanent changes to our kids' bodies.
Though I accept that we shouldn't be allowed to sell ourselves into slavery, it isn't clear to me why this implies a prohibition against harvesting your own organs. And I definitely don't think your duties to your own body forbid you from modifying it. Your right to own yourself doesn't translate into a prohibition against getting a piercing or a tattoo. So if your kid is legally part of your own body, it seems you still have the right to brand your kids' face.
There's the other issue of emancipation. If a child is his parent's property, then the parent has the right to hide and lock away the child. So even if your kid wants to leave your house, you have every right to confine him and subject him to whatever treatment he was trying to flee. And since he is your property, you have the right to exclude others' use of him. No one would have the right to take your kid from you, even if you are obviously abusing him.
This holds even if your kid is legally part of your body, and not just your property. Other people's right to rescue your child cannot be translated from your duty to take care of your own body. If your duties to yourself excuse violent intervention into your life from others on your behalf, then other people have the right to kidnap you and force feed you if you go on a hunger strike. I doubt this is the implication we want. Your rights and responsibilities over your own body do not mean other people's right to force you to take care of yourself. If your kid is part of your body, then other people still don't have the right to protect your kid (who is your body) from your "self"-destructive actions.
Parental rights have to be different from property rights. Our traditional notion of parental rights are in the right direction: You have the right to do what you want for your kid, so long as your actions meet certain standards that outline the child's best interest. Property rights don't embody this. Property rights allow you to treat an object according to your interest, not the "object's" interest. How we discern these standards is a real big can of worms that I'll pry open in a future post.
Monday, July 27, 2009
Sex and Right, Part 1
There seems to have been a three-shelf hierarchy of rules and prohibitions:
A. At the top were those things that should be preached against, condemned, and prohibited or regulated by law, like homicide, abortion, drug and alcohol abuse, psychoactive drugs in general, homosexuality, lewd behavior, etc.;
B. Next were those things that should be preached against and condemned, but not banned by law, like unBiblical religions (including those based on versions of the Bible that aren't faithful translations of the Textus Receptus), sending your kids to a public school, or lying naked around the house; and at the bottom,
C. Those things that should be left entirely up to the parents, like how many times a kid should be spanked for using foul language, whether the kids should be homeschooled or sent to a Christian school, whether it's appropriate to see musicals, whether there should be a TV in the home, whether the girls should be allowed to wear pajama pants around the house or whether they should wear ankle-length night gowns, and whether the parents may dance alone together behind closed doors.
In other words, as a fundamentalist, I had the liberal notion that some parts of my life are other people's business and other parts are "between me and God". I wasn't the only one who had this idea. After one particular man's wife had their eighth or ninth live birth (live birth, that is!) the pastor of the church congratulated them from the pulpit and plainly said that how many kids that couple wants is entirely their own business. (It is rumored that the man wanted twelve children, and from what I hear his wife has reached his goal.)
Of course, different people have different ideas of what things should go into which shelf. And they have different ways to go about placing things into the different shelves. This is why I'm writing this series -- to examine how people place different things into different shelves.
One way some people do it is teleology. They look at what an act tends to bring, and infer that it is meant to bring that, that it's designed for that function, and that performing that act in a way that goes against that purpose is an abuse of the act. What does sex bring about? Babies! And so, an essential purpose of sex is to make babies, and "any use whatsoever of matrimony exercised in such a way that the act is deliberately frustrated in its natural power to generate life is an offense against the law of God and of nature, and those who indulge in such are branded with the guilt of a grave sin." According to the Catholic Church, married people are perfectly entitled to enjoy sex, so long as they're making babies while they're at it.
Since anal sex goes against the procreational purpose of sex (a woman can't get pregnant from it), it is a sexual perversion, and -- according to the Catholic Church -- belongs either in shelf A or B. Other sexual acts which go against the procreational purpose are masturbation and sex with contraception. Yes, according to the Catholic Church, using a condom, pill, or shot is sexually immoral, even if you're married.
The only passage of the Bible that comes anywhere close to mentioning the procreational purpose rule is the story of Onan. But God struck Onan dead, not because he released somewhere other than a woman's vagina, but because he rejected his God-given duty to beget children with his dead brother's widow.
The lesson to take home for now is this: if we want to use theological and scriptural reasons to place something in shelf A or B and not C, then we have to at least understand that there are different kinds of theological and scriptural reasons, and that more than one of them are wrong.
Sunday, July 26, 2009
Correction
This actually isn't true. A very popular theory among libertarians is the title transfer theory of contract. This theory, shared by Rothbard, Kinsella, Long, brainpolice2, and me, states that the obligations in a contract exist only as conditions for receiving something. They do not hold by virtue of a mere promise. If A wants x from B, he has to do y. And if B wants y from A, he has to do x. If A doesn't want to do y, fine. But he then isn't entitled to anything from B. B can then refuse to do x for A, but he can't force A to do y.
If I am a landlord and you are my tenant, you are entitled to part of my property only by my permission. You can get that permission by paying me rent, and keeping certain obligations that are laid out in a contract that both of us agree to. But that isn't the only way you keep my permission.
If our contract happens to not forbid loud parties, and you have a few loud parties, I have no obligation to put up with your noise. I can kick you off my property even if you didn't agree to not have loud parties. If it's my property, I can decide who uses it, for what purpose, and on what grounds. Saying otherwise is to say that my permission isn't necessary for other people to be entitled to my services.
If our contract happens to not forbid animal abuse, and I find you abusing your animal on my property, I have no obligation to be polite. I can kick you off my property even if you didn't agree to not abuse animals on it. If it's my property, I can decide who uses it and who doesn't, etc.
If I convert to some leftist religion which dictates that families of the same race should not live adjacent to each other, I have every right to demand that the tenants switch up their places, and to kick out those who refuse to. If it's my property...
By acting that whimsically, though, I might be forfeiting my coverage with my defence agency and my dispute resolution organization. I am only entitled to their services on the condition that I follow the rules they lay down. If following a certain eviction procedure is a condition of my coverage, and I bypass that procedure, then my insurance providers have every right to drop my coverage. But they don't have the right to force me to accomodate the people I don't want on my property.
So no, a landlord theoretically doesn't need a provision against animal abuse written into the lease in order to have the right to evict animal abusers.
Followers
About Me
- Isaiah
- I am a part-time philosopher and a former immigration paralegal with a BA in philosophy and a paralegal certificate from UC San Diego.